Sergio Martinez getting disrespected in the P4P ranks

[Russian Crushin]

I think he's got good movement and elite quickness. Not a bad punch for a guy that started at WW either.

10-8.5?

Get out of here.

Comparing him to Floyd who is obviously a 10, what # would you give sergio?

[jaskieee]

Ok how bout this. Who the **** Martinez beat outside of Paul Williams and Pavlik.

Seriously Montiel and Vic Darchinyan are both better than them two but yet somehow martinez is the one who gets disrespected. Dude Resume is nothing great outside of those two. Donaire has more quality win and has been dominating everybody. Imagine being a pacquaio fan and people saying Martinez should be p4p number 1 even though his resume is nowhere near as great as pacquaio at all. Now the questions should be why the **** floyd is still number 2 fighting nobody.


Also add the fact that Martinez lost to paul williams in the first fight.(even though it was very close). That is why donaire is ahead of martinez because donaire hasn't lost since his 2nd bout while Martinez lost last year against paul williams.

Exactly, Martinez is a great fighter and had two big performances in 2010 but the year before that he had a draw and a loss to Kermit Cintron and Paul Williams respectively.

[Zarco]

Exactly, Martinez is a great fighter and had two big performances in 2010 but the year before that he had a draw and a loss to Kermit Cintron and Paul Williams respectively.

Maybe he should have fought the Manuel Vargas's and Hernan Marquez's of his division that way he would be 4-0 in his last 4 fights lmao.

[Sweet Jesus]

Comparing him to Floyd who is obviously a 10, what # would you give sergio?

Using a 10 point must system: An 8.5 at the lowest.

[Castor_Troy]

10-8.5 on skill. Wow. Seriously. Wow.

Fine.

Answer this. If they are the same size. Who would you bet on? Donairre or Martinez?

[Castor_Troy]

I think you got that messed up my Pinoy friend. Pavlik is an alcoholic former MW champ. Something than a Pinoy will never accomplish because they don't make you guys taller than 5'6". Williams is the bum that went 1-1 vs. Martinez.

See how IGNORANT you are my black friend.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ceferino_Garcia

http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?hum...9601&cat=boxer

[Sweet Jesus]

See how IGNORANT you are my black friend.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ceferino_Garcia

http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?hum...9601&cat=boxer

I've been proven wrong. 5'7" and the MW champ.

By the way, I'm your Ukrainian friend.

[Castor_Troy]

I've been proven wrong. 5'7" and the MW champ.

By the way, I'm your Ukrainian friend.

well i'll take you word for it.

[Zarco]

Wow so now Nonito Donaire is absolutely flawless future P4P ATG#1. Like I said in my original post I could only imagine if Donaire had completely KOd a boxer who was P4P#3 and towered over him....wow

[Castor_Troy]

Wow so now Nonito Donaire is absolutely flawless future P4P ATG#1. Like I said in my original post I could only imagine if Donaire had completely KOd a boxer who was P4P#3 and towered over him....wow

P4P = 'who will win if they are the same size'

its not a ranking of fighters with the best resumes.