Comments Thread For: Undeniable Donaire: BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top 10

[Mr. Philadel]

Pac
Martinez
Floyd
JMM
Donaire
Wlad
Bradley
B.Hop
Froch/Ward
Agbeko

my list is better than the NSB list

[Moop]

2010 P4P:

1. Martinez: #1 MW Pavlik, #1 MW PWILL
2. Mayweather: #1 WW Mosley
3. Pac: #5 WW Clottey, Not rated Margarito

What this guy said

[crold1]

too high....................too soon

At 168, Ward has the single best win, Froch has the best run (maybe in the sport; 4-1 against that crop is sick), and Bute might have the most talent.

None has firmly established himself as THE man at 168. When one does, I'll bring that guy in high. For now, I don't think they are that separable.

[minasyan]

pac
floyd
marquez
wlad
martinez
donaire

you would think he might be higher but the fighters ahead of him have been doing what he just did for years now

[kadyo's]

B-b-but these rankings are based on 'skill'..

LMAO!!!!

Hey man, whatever happened to that sig of yours with floyd looking smitten with the king?

[miron_lang]

Pound for pound rankings should not be debatable. Everyone has the right to put whoever they like. It Mythical its Fantasy. Its not ultimately about resume its about "Who you think is the best is they are all the same size" or "Who will win if they are the same size"

Here's mine nobody should question it.

1. Tyson Fury
2. Tye Fields
3. Brian Nielsen
4. Manny Pacquiao
5. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
6. Steve Cunningham
7. Juan Manuel Marquez
8. Charlie Zelenof
9. Bert Batawang
10. Donnie Nietes

[bojangles1987]

Pound for pound rankings should not be debatable. Everyone has the right to put whoever they like. It Mythical its Fantasy. Its not ultimately about resume its about "Who you think is the best is they are all the same size" or "Who will win if they are the same size"

Here's mine nobody should question it.

1. Tyson Fury
2. Tye Fields
3. Brian Nielsen
4. Manny Pacquiao
5. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
6. Steve Cunningham
7. Juan Manuel Marquez
8. Charlie Zelenof
9. Bert Batawang
10. Donnie Nietes

I always thought the whole fun of p4p lists was debating them.

[| THE KING |]

LMAO!!!!

Hey man, whatever happened to that sig of yours with floyd looking smitten with the king?

The one where he looked like a fan being in the presence of the king? Donaire got my respect for getting Montiel to do the la cucuracha dance on his back.. (didn't expect him to make it easy.. Montiel is no pushover) so he is in my sig temporarily.

[ShoulderRoll]

At 168, Ward has the single best win, Froch has the best run (maybe in the sport; 4-1 against that crop is sick), and Bute might have the most talent.

None has firmly established himself as THE man at 168. When one does, I'll bring that guy in high. For now, I don't think they are that separable.

So basically whoever establishes himself will have gone from not even being in the top 10 to all of a sudden being ranked very high? Hmm, not very consistent IMO.

It seems you don't think highly of what guys are doing in some of these tournaments Cliff. None of the Super Sixers make your list and neither do any of the fighters in the bantamweight tournament.

[Dave Rado]

pac
floyd
marquez
wlad
martinez
donaire

you would think he might be higher but the fighters ahead of him have been doing what he just did for years now

When did any of the fighters ahead of him on your list other than Pacquiao knock out a fighter ranked in The Ring's P4P top 10 in under two rounds???

And who, in your list, apart from Pacquiao and Donaire, have knocked out two P4P top 10 fighters in less than 5 rounds, in the last four years?