Comments Thread For: Undeniable Donaire: BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top 10

[komandante]

As I've posted earlier My P4P Rankings.

1. Manny Pacquiao (PHI)
2. Nonito Donaire (PHI)
3. Floyd Mayweather jr (USA)
4. Sergio Martinez (ARG)
5. JuanMa Lopez (PUR)
6. JuanMa Marquez (MEX)
7. Bernard Hopkins (USA)
8. Wladimir Klitscho (UKR)
9. Amir Khan (UK)
10. Tim Bradley (USA)

Almost the same with Boxing.Scene

[beatnutts]

p4p ranking is all about someone's opinion so i don't know why people get so angry. Personally i don't know how some people have Donaire over Mayweather, Sergio, or Juan Manuel Lopez but in my opinion, he's right behind those guys. Seriously, i know people that think Donaire is #1 and that's fine also.

[myCoCainE]

HAHAHA! Eat **** suckers! I'm gonna root for Mosley now so by May, Nonaire will be #1 P4P.

[jjbj2]

I think Sergio Martinez deserves the number 2 spot and JMM the number 3 spot. Donaire is at least a 4 but a deserving 5 though. I was thinking Andrew Ward deserves to be at least number 4 or in the top 5. Pac is number 1 no more explanation to that.

Miguel Cotto number 6.

[LeadUppercut]

Look at people crying about mythical and opinionated P4P rankings.

Bump.....

Tamis, I wish everybody realised just how good that post was.

[el gringo]

I saw this kid Donaire demolish Vic Darchinyan and now Montiel. He's got power in his hands. Believe me, he is going to be the successor to his countryman Pacman.

[Ryannn]

not shocked with bscene's rankings.

they put floyd back at number 2 for beating a fat lightweight ffs.

[pasawayako]

Donaire will be the next #1 lb#lb king after pac retire in boxing.

[| THE KING |]

not shocked with bscene's rankings.

they put floyd back at number 2 for beating a fat lightweight ffs.

B-b-but these rankings are based on 'skill'..

[Ryannn]

B-b-but these rankings are based on 'skill'..

i disagree with the rankings, i think donaire should be around number 4.

but it is alot more acceptable than floyd being put that high fighting a tune up fight.