Comments Thread For: Undeniable Donaire: BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top 10

[Pullcounter]

nonito at #2 is kinda jumping the gun, but seeing *****s get angry by having their idol placed after another pinoy is priceless.

martinez should be placed above JMM.

1) pac
2) wifebeater
3) martinez
4) jmm
5) nonito

IMHO is more realistic.

but I agree with cliff that if pac keeps fighting guys like marg and mosley, I won't get mad if cliff puts nonito above pac should nonito clean out 118.

[Chups]

Wasn't ignoring him...had him just outside the top 10 before the fight. Opp caught up to the talent and the talent is SICK.



Being fixed...I used to live in Alameda County. Drrrr...

Crold, Nonito is from San Leandro.......a Northern California city.

[Chups]

Being fixed...I used to live in Alameda County. Drrrr...

Gotcha.

[wazaa.]

That's fine, because is P4P is just your opinion. You can put Khan #1 P4P if you really want is all opinion.

Divisional rankings is based more on facts, resume, accomplishment in your respected divisions.

P4P is mythical is based on opinion.

Yeah well the difference is that my opinion is worthless because I'm practically a nobody. BoxingScene (one of the biggest boxing websites in the world) giving a ludacris ranking like that... **** is different.

[crold1]

Crold, Nonito is from San Leandro.......a Northern California city.

Which is where Alameda County is my oh so helpful amigo.

[Tamis!]

That's fine, because is P4P is just your opinion. You can put Khan #1 P4P if you really want is all opinion.

Divisional rankings is based more on facts, resume, accomplishment in your respected divisions.

P4P is mythical is based on opinion.

Don't bother Jro, I tried to tell him but he instead kept dragging me to a "FLoyd this FLoyd that and I'd get angry" and ****. They can give Floyd, Amir or any boxer any title all they want and I Dont Give A Sh!t.

[Mr. Philadel]

Look at people crying about mythical and opinionated P4P rankings.

if they had put Sergio at the top spot after he sent P.Will face first to the canvas and dropped Manny to the silver #2....you would've been heated....so fall back for hot 60 seconds bro

NOW...WTF is Sergio doing at 5?!?....no ****in way!!!!!....dude is EASY a top 3 fighter P4P.....hands down!!!....not even trying to disrespect nobody...but this list is wack!!!

[crold1]

nonito at #2 is kinda jumping the gun, but seeing *****s get angry by having their idol placed after another pinoy is priceless.

martinez should be placed above JMM.

1) pac
2) wifebeater
3) martinez
4) jmm
5) nonito

IMHO is more realistic.

but I agree with cliff that if pac keeps fighting guys like marg and mosley, I won't get mad if cliff puts nonito above pac should nonito clean out 118.

I though rating him almost solely off Darch was jumping the gun. I was reminded why some did after I saw him tear Sidorenko to shreds. He dented Montiel's freaking face. I don't think anyone can jump the gun now. He's annihilated two of the most accomplished little men in recent memory, a couple guys who will both be at least on the Hall ballot one day, both at the top of their game, and he didn't break a sweat.

This is how good Jones and Mayweather looked once upon a time when humiliating Toney or Corrales. I'm huge on resume, but sometimes a limited resume can be overcome when the talent is THAT wicked.

Here we are.

[Sinisterevo]

yeah I think they get too excited the day after a fight...which is understandable. The day after Martinez knocked out Williams he was ranked at -1.

Donaire is top 5 for sure. Mayweather #1, Pac #2, Martinez #3.

[MrClutch85]

Skill and Talent wise Nonito deserves to be Number 2 Sergio number 3 Andre Ward 4 Juanma 5 JMM 6 Bradley 7 Wladamir 8 Hopkins 9 Gamboa 10