Will you rate Donaire higher than Martinez?

[Bushbaby]

I'm sorry but I understand wanting to put Donaire very high on the mythical pfp list,That is fine.But if Ur planning to move someone down,it shouldn't be Martinez.Floyd is inactive & Manny Pacman hasn't beaten a really credible opponent since the catchweight Cotto fight.

Martinez in all reality should be #1 based on opposition alone,followed by Donaire,for the same reason.Floyd & Manny shouldn't be 1 & 2 for the reasons stated above.Rearrange pfp list if U want,but don't discredit Martinez & try to move him down to do it.Move Floyd's inactive a$$ & stop giving Manny breaks for fighting shot fighters.

[TOBYLEE1]

Martinez has more momentum and even had a hard time finding his next fight cause nobody wants to risk fighting him.

A couple of good wins against highly regarded fighters will get Nonito up there.

[devildg]

I'm sorry but I understand wanting to put Donaire very high on the mythical pfp list,That is fine.But if Ur planning to move someone down,it shouldn't be Martinez.Floyd is inactive & Manny Pacman hasn't beaten a really credible opponent since the catchweight Cotto fight.

Martinez in all reality should be #1 based on opposition alone,followed by Donaire,for the same reason.Floyd & Manny shouldn't be 1 & 2 for the reasons stated above.Rearrange pfp list if U want,but don't discredit Martinez & try to move him down to do it.Move Floyd's inactive a$$ & stop giving Manny breaks for fighting shot fighters.

Clottey wasn't credible?

[Zarco]

I have Nonito higher than Martinez because of the whole resume. Martinez I'd give the edge recently because Williams, Pavlik and Sergiy trumps Montiel but Donaire has rarely lost rounds. That in itself is better imo. My top 10 is:

1. Pacquaio
2. Mayweather
3. Donaire
4. Martinez
5. JMM
6. Hopkins
7. Wlad
8. Bradley
9. Lopez
10. Ward

The whole resume c'mon dude? Matinez's fights with 5 inch taller Williams, 4 inch taller Pavlik, Cintron all these takes a huge dookie on Donaires Resume. It was kinda sad that HBO placed Maldonado and Concepcion as notable wins for Donaire because they are Alex Bunema status if not lower.