Will you rate Donaire higher than Martinez?

[MOTHER DUCKER]

I'm a huge Khan fan but i don't know how you can have Amir and Bradley on your list and not Froch

Froch is one of, if not THE most underappreciated fighters in the sport

Exactly i am not sure how he has Lopez at 5 either especially with no Froch..

Froch didn't get outclassed by Dirrel.. Go watch AA vs Dirrel for 10 rounds and Froch vs AA now that is Outclassed.

I had dirrel probably winning by a round or 2 vs Froch.. technically he is far better but he didn't show it that night and fought like a ***** imo apart from round 10.

[Visceral]

Martinez is higher than Donaire without question.

Lets see Nonito beat Gamboa or Juanma; then we'll talk.

Agreed. And it will get harder for Donaire to pass him up as Martinez fights more top guys.

[ronnie_N.]

Agreed. And it will get harder for Donaire to pass him up as Martinez fights more top guys.

since when?.. his wins against pavlik and williams was only last year...
i might be wrong, but martinez defeated nobody until he fought williams the first time on the last month of 2009 (which he lost)....

donaire blitz an undefeated darchinyan back in 2007... winning 2 belts in the process

[La Zorrita]

how bout no??
martinez > donaire

[Rome-By-Ko]

IMO Martinez is the third best fighter in the sport,Martinez is beating big MW while Doniare should have moved up like a year ago..Guys at 118 are to small imo,I give him much credit he deserves to be on the P4P list but tbh Froch should be before this guy and Martinez is def before him on my list..But ya know how boxing is,what have ya done for me today..How he replaces a guy who is the MW champ and a guy who beat another P4P opponent(just like he did)is beyond me??

[Rome-By-Ko]

since when?.. his wins against pavlik and williams was only last year...
i might be wrong, but martinez defeated nobody until he fought williams the first time on the last month of 2009 (which he lost)....

donaire blitz an undefeated darchinyan back in 2007... winning 2 belts in the process

Wrong Martinez fought Cintron and Bunema and in reality KO'd both..

[Rome-By-Ko]

I have Nonito higher than Martinez because of the whole resume. Martinez I'd give the edge recently because Williams, Pavlik and Sergiy trumps Montiel but Donaire has rarely lost rounds. That in itself is better imo. My top 10 is:

1. Pacquaio
2. Mayweather
3. Donaire
4. Martinez
5. JMM
6. Hopkins
7. Wlad
8. Bradley
9. Lopez
10. Ward

Donaire has not lost a rd because he's fighting smaller fighters,Martinez is fighting bigger fighters/punchers and dominating and leaving no doubt..Martinez resume is far better then Donaire's as well..

Froch should be on the P4P list that is all..

[jrosales13]

since when?.. his wins against pavlik and williams was only last year...
i might be wrong, but martinez defeated nobody until he fought williams the first time on the last month of 2009 (which he lost)....

donaire blitz an undefeated darchinyan back in 2007... winning 2 belts in the process

So what you're saying is Donaire fights a top fighter once every 3 years?

Anyways I personally have Martinez higher. But, is all opinion. Doesn't really matter.

My personal P4P list is

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. JMM
4. Martinez
5. Donaire
6. Bradley
7. Wlad
8. Froch
9. Hopkins
10. Wonjongkam

The next 5 in no order will be: Moreno, Adamek, Ward, Segura, Cotto.

[Rome-By-Ko]

So what you're saying is Donaire fights a top fighter once every 3 years?

Anyways I personally have Martinez higher. But, is all opinion. Doesn't really matter.

My personal P4P list is

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. JMM
4. Martinez
5. Donaire
6. Bradley
7. Wlad
8. Froch
9. Hopkins
10. Wonjongkam

The next 5 in no order will be: Moreno, Adamek, Ward, Segura, Cotto.

Good list...

[ummeed]

this is donaire's first huge victory in years, i know majority of the boxing fans are already aware of his skill and talent but he still needs to work on converting them to something that would reflect on his resume before he advances in the rankings.