Which win is more impressive, Mayweather vs Corrales or Pacquiao vs Barrera 1?

[Bermuda]

barrera was p4p#3, lineal champ at 126, and is a future hof and considered one of the best mexican fighters of all time.......

so yah pac vs barrera 1 >>>>>> floyd vs corrales

[tangalog2200]

Floyd's skill is unmatched in boxing today. You better have boxing skills if you don't want to be embarrassed by PBF.

uh uh...but floyd is avoiding up to this date the guy with no boxing skill, one-dimension midget etc etc

[straightleft]

Barerra win is far more impressive imo. Barerra is a bona fide legitimate ATG hall of famer who was no less top 3 p4p in the entire sport only behind roy jones and floyd when manny dominated him. Barerra was on a 8 fight winning streak before he lost to manny and went on a 6 fight winning streak after he lost to manny only losing to another bona fide ATG in marquez whome he dropped in the fight.

Corrales was a solid champion but not really hall of fame material.

I can't deny this fact.

[fabie]

Comparing Barrera to Corrales is of no contest. Barrera is one of ATG Mexican fighter and one of the best in his era. Who was Corrales at the time or anytime?

[daggum]

barrera had beaten morales, hamed, kennedy mckinney and tons more
corrales had beaten robert garcia, manfredy, and derrik gainer and thats basically it

floyd beat a one dimensional come forward fighter
pacquiao beat an all around great boxer

with all that said i gotta go with calzaghe over lacy trumping both

[bojangles1987]

LOL, people actually voted for Mayweather-Corrales.

[SlySlickSmooth]

Barrera was the far more accomplished and greater fighter at the time he lost to Pacquaio, he was KOd by Manny during a great great streak of wins.

[$tate of Mind]

Mayweather had the better performance, while Pacquiao had the better win. It just depends on one's personal preference.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Manny over MAB...

Mab was a much better fighter than corrales..

Corrales had alot of problems leading up to that fight,,,

MAB was at his peak, he had just defeated undefeated prince and undefeated morales,, He was the legit kingpin of the featherweight division

A better win IMO

[GRboxing]

Pacquiao over Barrera