Vote now, Would floyd still be undefeated if...

[lfc19titles]

keep the votes coming

[lfc19titles]

split really at the moment

[daggum]

no way. there is a reason he avoided so many top fighters. how can so many people believe in floyd when he didn't even believe in himself?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

i would have liked to see him get robbed


not because i hate that racist, woman-beating douchebag, but to see how he would bounce back after a heartbreaking defeat


does he fold or does he come back like a beast...

[Mitch5]

He fought the best fighters in his class at their prime or very close to their prime?

So lets say and I apologise for my spelling of names

Tzyu at 140 who was the man, floyd clearly ducked him

at 147 a prime cotto?

a prime margarito? remember margarito coming up to floyd at a party, floyd left shaking when giving an interview saying he would give him a fight, instead floyd retired for a year to avoid the best guys

a prime mosley at 135 or even say at 147 in the early 2000s (instead he fought him when he was nearly 40 and coming off a 18 month lay off)


finally a prime pac who just beat cotto?

also add kostya, forest and winky to the list

above are the guys floyd ducked for sure, there are other fighters but there is a bit of leeway on his part for them

saw this post so add these guys to the mix, would floyd beat all of these11

floyd beats a prime kosta tzyu and why is he on your list twice kosta and tzyu are the same person..Floyd beats a prime cotto in which i think would have been a great fight. floyd beats a "prime" margarito.. Floyd beats a prime shane at 135 and thats a horrible example because wanted that fight bad at 135. matter of fact floyd beats shane at any point in time..it just wouldve been a better fight at 135..a prime pac fight i think floyd wins but pac has good chance at winning it..and winky and forrest gives him the most trouble but seeing how vernons prime was in the early 2000s and at ww and floyd being at 135 makes that fight difficult to make .. and winky always being two weight classes above floyd makes that difficult to make also. so with a run like shane at 135, tzyu at 140, cotto at 147, margs at 147, and pac at 147.i think floyd beats them with the biggest tests being shane at 135 and and pac at 147

[Steak]

hes not undefeated in my eyes anyway.

I think Casamayor and Tsyzu would have given him a fair amount of trouble at the lighter weights. I think he more or less had 130 in his pocket though.

[lfc19titles]

Yeah i agree

[Kagami Taiga]

one comment, why is winky on the list?? when was the last time winky fgought at 147??? and when he did, he defintiely wasnt prime winky. take him off.

the same thing with forrest. by the time floyd moved up to 147 forrest was gone. ppl learn ur fight history.

[Heeb]

I think so. Fantasy fights don't prove anything anyway. Floyd fought who he fought and speculation won't make him a greater or less great fighter.

[Larry the boss]

yes..think thats what really makes people mad..cause hes so good yet he can be so much better.....its like a person who doesnt study yet always makes b's...