Poll: Which win was more convincing, JMM vs Pac 2 or Floyd vs Castillo?

[Heeb]

Both fights could've gone either way, so neither is more convincing than the other in my opinion.

[2120]

thread starter needs a third option

Neither. both floyd and pac lost those fights in my eyes!

either way they were both close fights

[_original_]

Both were close and could've gone either way, the difference being that Floyd totally schooled him in a rematch and Pacquiao refused to give Marquez a third shot to end all speculation.

[letsgobrady]

most scorecards have floyd winning the first 4-5 rounds of the castillo fight so how is that fight a robbery?and for those who feel like floyd did lose must feel as if floyd lost every round after round 5 yet at the same time it's hard for them to see marquez win every round besides the 1st round of the first fight.i had the floyd castillo fight 6-6 or 7-5 for floyd and the marquez-manny fight i had it 6-6 maybe 7-5 marquez when i first watched it but i watch it now and i score it 8-4 marquez

[puga]

Both were close and could've gone either way, the difference being that Floyd totally schooled him in a rematch and Pacquiao refused to give Marquez a third shot to end all speculation.

only if the piss drinker does'nt keep pricing himself out , maybe he would've gotten a fight instead of shane...

[RIZO24]

Both were close and could've gone either way, the difference being that Floyd totally schooled him in a rematch and Pacquiao refused to give Marquez a third shot to end all speculation.

Exactly!!!!!

[Pullcounter]

pac actually put jmm on his back.... hence more convincing.

[bojangles1987]

Neither won convincingly. I guess since I think Pacquiao won, though by the slimmest of possible margins, him. Mayweather lost the first Castillo fight, no matter how many times I watch it.

[Horus]

Do not reply to this Post unless you post your scorecard


Mayweather VS. Castillo I

Judges Scorecards
Anek Hongtongkam, Thailand: 116-111 Mayweather
John Keane, England: 115-111 Mayweather
Jerry Roth, Nevada: 115-111 Mayweather

Horus Scorecard

R1: Mayweather
R2: Mayweather
R3: Mayweather
The first starting to heat up as castillo finally gets the car out of neutral. But he still lost the round.Mayweather landed more. Floyd was jabbing to the body was to highlights of the round. Castillo was missing just about everything
R4: Mayweather
this is the only round I feel was not a sure round for Mayweather, because castillo did more than he did in the previous rounds. And Mayweather showed the first signs that he was getting uncomfortable as he starts switching to southpaw. Castillo opening up more and grabbing is not a reason to score a round for him. The most he did was trying to rough Mayweather up this round, but not landing nearly the more effective punches mayweather was landing.Castillo did alot of grabing and punching in this round, to the point the ref had to warned him to stop.
R5: Mayweather
Best Punch of the round came at 2:10, clean, hard, and loud. Once again Mayweather dominates the majority of the round, and castillo came on late. Castillo didnt land any good shots until 40 seconds left in the round. Even still Mayweather closes the round with his trademark Pullcounter right hand.
R6: Castillo
R7: Mayweather
Mayweather dominated the majority of this round. countering the **** out of castillo and making Castillo miss. Castillo comes on at the end of the round but you just cant forget about the previous 2:30 seconds of the round.
R8: Mayweather
(10-8) point deduction for castillo. Mayweather's jab won this round, castillo once again grabs and punches and loses the point.
R9: Castillo
R10: Mayweather
(-1 point deduction for round scored 9-9)
R11: Castillo
R12: Castillo

Horus Scorecard: 115-111