Poll: Which win was more convincing, JMM vs Pac 2 or Floyd vs Castillo?

**RL_GMA** · 02-02-2011, 03:30 PM

I had Pac winning the 2nd fight (though it was really close). I've watched Mayweather vs Castillo about 4 times in its entirety and I still have Castillo winning that fight.

**Twako** · 02-02-2011, 04:11 PM

i had pac winning but it was real close, the KD made the only diff.

but floyd-luis was not that close to have gone either way.

**Chopper417** · 02-02-2011, 04:28 PM

Damn really tough question....I have watched and scored both fights multiple times. Even as a Floyd fan I can admit that the second time I went back and watched it I had Castillo winning by 2 points. The Pac-Marquez 2 was extremely close as well but every time I have scored it I have had Pac winning by 1 point.

**Franco2012** · 02-02-2011, 04:36 PM

Pacquiao won both fights,and Floyd lost both fights to Castillo.
Thats the difference!

**D4thincarnation** · 02-02-2011, 04:38 PM

Well Pacquiao's fights with Marquez were close, only a round in it. I had Pacquiao winning but I could see how some had Marquez winning, with some rounds close to call.

Mayweather vs Castillo not even close, Castillo won fair and square and got robbed by the judges. Castillo by about 4 rounds.

**RubenSonny** · 02-02-2011, 04:43 PM

Originally posted by D4thincarnation

Well Pacquiao's fights with Marquez were close, only a round in it. I had Pacquiao winning but I could see how some had Marquez winning, with some rounds close to call.

Mayweather vs Castillo not even close, Castillo won fair and square and got robbed by the judges. Castillo by about 4 rounds.

**MXboxingfan** · 02-02-2011, 04:47 PM

I thought Pacquiao lost both fights against Marquez and Mayweather won both fights against Castillo.

**Steak** · 02-02-2011, 04:53 PM

Floyd vs Castillo, for me. Castillo did simply too much damage and landed too many punches, especially to the body.(which I dont think people count enough while scoring)

I could make a fairer argument for Pacquiao winning the Marquez fight, although I thought Marquez won that one as well.

oh wait...looking at the title...uh...
I thought Castillo won the Mayweather fight more convincingly than Marquez winning Pacquiao II...so....
Pacquiao's victory was more convinging, even though I thought he lost....?

**Franco2012** · 02-02-2011, 05:05 PM

Originally posted by D4thincarnation

Well Pacquiao's fights with Marquez were close, only a round in it. I had Pacquiao winning but I could see how some had Marquez winning, with some rounds close to call.

Mayweather vs Castillo not even close, Castillo won fair and square and got robbed by the judges. Castillo by about 4 rounds.

Exactly Castillo won 8 rounds to 4.

This was one of worse robbery of all time,if not the worsE!

Poll: Which win was more convincing, JMM vs Pac 2 or Floyd vs Castillo?