Who is a GREATER fighter and Higher on All Time List? Marquez or Mosley?!

[Woosha]

BALCO scandal aside, Sugars resume pawns JMM

[Piper the Great]

MOSLEY... JMM is known for a draw & a loss

[Thread Stealer]

BALCO scandal aside, Sugars resume pawns JMM

Only in resume by opposition faced, not opposition beaten.

Shane's resume of wins is weak outside of De La Hoya. De La Hoya 1 is by far his best win, followed by Margarito. The rest of his quality wins are over decent contenders, and a decent titleholder in Holiday. Vargas looked better than expected in their first bout, but it's still a 2006 Vargas, a far cry from the Vargas of 1998-2000.

Likewise, Marquez has a number of wins over decent contenders, an aging champ in Casamayor, a win over an aging but still formidable great in Barrera, and the draw and close loss to a great in Pacquiao.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Marquez. Hes a better boxer, better resume and he aint a juicer

[Cash Cow]

The contract was for both to come no more than 144lbs.

Floyd lied and violated that contract stipulation, so that he can come much heavier, and weighed-in about 158-161lbs when he stepped in the ring with JMM.

We saw a weltweight fighter, fight a Middleweight that night.

We did? was their official weights that night?

[Rolaz]

In the past, I suggested, that the two should face each other!

And so, if you really want to know who is better between the two,
Then by all means, let them settle the issue inside the Ring!

[Instinto]

Their resume list is pretty much similar. They have few good wins over top fighters and beaten lot of good contenders, but Mosley's contenders are more familiar to boxing world. Shane is 2- and JMM is 3-division champions. Mosley on the other hand was beaten quite a lot of times.

[miron_lang]

Their resume list is pretty much similar. They have few good wins over top fighters and beaten lot of good contenders, but Mosley's contenders are more familiar to boxing world. Shane is 2- and JMM is 3-division champions. Mosley on the other hand was beaten quite a lot of times.

Shane is also 3 Division Champion ( Lightweight, Welter and 154 )

[Instinto]

We did? was their official weights that night?

Nope, Mayweather refused to weigh-in that night. Marquez's weight was 148 pounds, even fighting Diaz and Katsidis Marquez weighs around 148 pounds. If you look Pac's unofficial weights at fight nights they are also 148 pounds. Guys like Cotto, Clottey, Floyd refuse to weigh-in because they weigh in the range of 160-170 at fight night.

[El_Forklift]

Juan Manuel cuz hes Mexican !!!