Who has a better resume??

[Roy Hobbs]

you can really tell who knows their boxing right away with questions like these & the answers you receive.

LOL at oscar being 1#. I guess we reward boxers who continually lose big fights not to mention a couple of big time gifts.

[savorduhflavor]

Well Floyd has Oscar and Mosley as well. Also has Chicanito, Hatton, Corrales, Castillo. If you're going to count Collazo, Floyd has Manfreddy, Corley, Chavez, and Hernandez all who were as good as Collazo.

You have to take into account the versions of the opponents he faced.

Comparing the Oscar Floyd fought and the one Mosley fought isn't fair. Hatton at 147 was never any god.

Corley as good as Collazo? I don't know about that.

Mosley fought these people at their primes. He fought the absolute best versions of Oscar, Forrest, Winky, Cotto, Margarito(maybe, we've heard a lot about that), Floyd, and soon Pac.

[EL_cano]

It's good thread,

Multiple battles with the best and still fighting.

My decision after Pacquiao retires.

[Steak]

whoops, picked Pacquiao before I saw DLH.

DLH has fought the best competition out there, most definitely.

[Kingdelboxeo]

It's good thread,

Multiple battles with the best and still fighting.

My decision after Pacquiao retires.

thanx bro.

[Visceral]

They are all amazing but I gotta go with Oscar.

Martinez started too late to have the best resume but his accomplishments are impressive to say the least.

Pacquiao has a very good one but too many whys with him. could have faught tougher guys once he got to the top and not had catch weights.

Mayweather: See Pacquiao. until they fight eachother they will be missing something win or lose

Mosley has always been willing but also very avoided and he has the drug stigma

Cotto has always been a great warrior who will fight any and beat most. not like he sucks just because his isn't quite as good as Oscar's

Oscar has had the longest career of any of them so one of them could catch him.
Oscar doesn't duck people and hasn't been overly protected.
His resume is a who's who of boxing. Win or lose he always faught the best.