If Shane Mosley was to retire tommorrow...

[Lucky466]

I dont think he would make it to the hall of fame. What has he really done at lightweight he was real good and looked like he had potential to make it to the hall but he never really beat anyone really meaningful there. And after lightweight all he really did was beat De La hoya once.

[Tha Greatest]

I dont think he would make it to the hall of fame. What has he really done at lightweight he was real good and looked like he had potential to make it to the hall but he never really beat anyone really meaningful there. And after lightweight all he really did was beat De La hoya once.

In controversial fashion also.

[Tha_Greatest]

for any reason...

Would he be a hall of famer?

hes only beaten 1 very good fighter 1 time and won a extremely controversial decision vs De La Hoya the second. If Mosley belongs in hall, you can make a argument For Junior Jones in hall because he beat Barrera twice, a hall of famer

[Tha_Greatest]

hes as in Mosley has only beaten 1 very good fighter 1 time and won a extremely controversial decision vs De La Hoya the second. If Mosley belongs in hall, you can make a argument For Junior Jones in hall because he beat Barrera twice, a hall of famer

I dont think Mosley is a sure hall of fame candidate yet

[InThisCorner]

As much as I love the guy (my favorite fighter) he has fallen in love with his power and moving up was his first mistake. His second mistake is moving back down. Hopefully he regains his amazing hand speed in the lower divisions and makes a mark on the 140 lb division although I don't think he will because he already had a tough time with Estrada...I'm just hoping the guy doesn't make ANY more ****** decisions, he's already made MANY (fighting Forrest only 6 months after his first loss), not having ANY tuneups for any of his losses. His losses are all against taller guys and it shows that the way you beat Sugar Shane is by jabbing.

[riz]

good honest fighter----- yes

hall of famer------ no way

[riz]

hes only beaten 1 very good fighter 1 time and won a extremely controversial decision vs De La Hoya the second. If Mosley belongs in hall, you can make a argument For Junior Jones in hall because he beat Barrera twice, a hall of famer

i think junior jones should be there man.. hes done a lot of things during his career and has fought the best

[Truth]

I would say NO!Because besides beating De La Hoya what has he done?

[Tha_Greatest]

I would say NO!Because besides beating De La Hoya what has he done?

THE TRUTH, this seems like a ****** question to some, who would you consider greater, Vernon(36-2) http://boxrec.com/record009047.html
Or Mosley(40-4) http://boxrec.com/record004952.html

[Truth]

THE TRUTH, this seems like a ****** question to some, who would you consider greater, Vernon(36-2) http://boxrec.com/record009047.html
Or Mosley(40-4) http://boxrec.com/record004952.html

Mosley because of his wins over Oscar and the reputation he built...but neither are hall of famers.