Is Cotto, Clottey, Margarito : cherry picked fight?

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ИATAS
    Banned
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Jul 2007
    • 36648
    • 2,509
    • 1,953
    • 50,835

    #11
    Originally posted by IMDAZED
    Not true. Pacquiao was a monster favorite over Clottey. That doesn't sound like an easy fight. Hell, I picked Clottey to quit. Most Pac fans worry about Manny's health like he's their dad so maybe they were worried but if Clottey fought on even terms with Cotto, what was he going to do against Manny?
    pac was a big favorite but I think everyone thought the fight would be more competitive than it was.

    I think the pattern here is they are all top rank fighters.

    Comment

    • 4773Y350NM3
      Interim Champion
      Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
      • Sep 2008
      • 897
      • 13
      • 0
      • 7,035

      #12
      Originally posted by IMDAZED
      Not true. Pacquiao was a monster favorite over Clottey. That doesn't sound like an easy fight. Hell, I picked Clottey to quit. Most Pac fans worry about Manny's health like he's their dad so maybe they were worried but if Clottey fought on even terms with Cotto, what was he going to do against Manny?

      Margarito had one fight in years and looked like ****. He was also a monster underdog.

      Your last statement sounds real dumb. Don't know why I thought I could have a debate here - peace.
      PAc was a favorite but that doesnt mean anything. Clottey fighting even terms with Cotto and Margs means a threat to anyone at 147 even against PAC. Is PAc that great now? I think you guys overrate him more than PAc fans lol.

      Margarito lose against Mosley, but Mosley didnt have a 17 pounds disadvantage. You think Mosley could do the same if he was the fighting Marg that night?

      Lets see here...

      If you think Cotto cant beat Floyd, damn you deep in Floyds ****.

      Margarito: As your fellow *****s Larry said Floyd having hard time against pressure fighter, and Marg is the poster boy of pressure fighter. You know why both Mosley and PAC beat Marg, they have the power to keep Marg at bay. You think the way FLoyd fight now, not using his footwork but staying on the packet will do him good against Marg? N to the O. NO!!!!!

      Clottey: Is a defensive fighter, Floyd doesnt have the output to make Clottey be defensive all the time. He has a great right hand, when he throws it. And its very hard to time somebody if you cant predict when he throws it. And FLoyd is all timing, and reflex.

      Comment

      • IMDAZED
        Fair but Firm
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • May 2006
        • 42644
        • 1,134
        • 1,770
        • 67,152

        #13
        Originally posted by ИATAS206
        pac was a big favorite but I think everyone thought the fight would be more competitive than it was.

        I think the pattern here is they are all top rank fighters.
        No, not everyone. Not me, that's for sure. And Manny being a big favorite means I wasn't the only one.

        Second, not only were they Top Rank, they were cherry-picked. Margarito? Come on.

        Cotto, on the other hand, was quite formidable. And a great matchup. I think anyone who hates/hated on that fight is, just that...a hater.

        Comment

        • IMDAZED
          Fair but Firm
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • May 2006
          • 42644
          • 1,134
          • 1,770
          • 67,152

          #14
          Originally posted by 4773Y350NM3
          PAc was a favorite but that doesnt mean anything. Clottey fighting even terms with Cotto and Margs means a threat to anyone at 147 even against PAC. Is PAc that great now? I think you guys overrate him more than PAc fans lol.

          Margarito lose against Mosley, but Mosley didnt have a 17 pounds disadvantage. You think Mosley could do the same if he was the fighting Marg that night?

          Lets see here...

          If you think Cotto cant beat Floyd, damn you deep in Floyds ****.

          Margarito: As your fellow *****s Larry said Floyd having hard time against pressure fighter, and Marg is the poster boy of pressure fighter. You know why both Mosley and PAC beat Marg, they have the power to keep Marg at bay. You think the way FLoyd fight now, not using his footwork but staying on the packet will do him good against Marg? N to the O. NO!!!!!

          Clottey: Is a defensive fighter, Floyd doesnt have the output to make Clottey be defensive all the time. He has a great right hand, when he throws it. And its very hard to time somebody if you cant predict when he throws it. And FLoyd is all timing, and reflex.
          FYI: I didn't read this. You're clearly just a d*ckrider.

          Comment

          • infamous larryx
            Banned
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Jan 2010
            • 10881
            • 512
            • 265
            • 1,565

            #15
            its WHEN he fought them

            cotto-damaged goods and had been looking bad-145

            clottey-fresh off of a loss

            margo-off a brutal beating by shane and a 1 year suspension

            Comment

            • 4773Y350NM3
              Interim Champion
              Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
              • Sep 2008
              • 897
              • 13
              • 0
              • 7,035

              #16
              Originally posted by IMDAZED
              No, not everyone. Not me, that's for sure. And Manny being a big favorite means I wasn't the only one.

              Second, not only were they Top Rank, they were cherry-picked. Margarito? Come on.

              Cotto, on the other hand, was quite formidable. And a great matchup. I think anyone who hates on that fight is, just that...a hater.
              Margarito lose to Mosley and Mosley lose to Cotto and Cotto lose to Margarito.

              Both of their losses is against the big names of 147, there is no ashamed on that. With that said they both have wins against the same big names on 147 also. And only PAc have wins on two of them without losing. And thats big accomplishment.

              Comment

              • SplitSecond
                Undisputed Champion
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Nov 2009
                • 23151
                • 1,715
                • 1,187
                • 85,044

                #17
                Originally posted by IMDAZED
                Cotto? Absolutely not. Clottey and Margarito? Absolutely yes.
                and the better options were....?

                berto? shane?
                eh...

                Comment

                • Left Hook Tua
                  VATNIK
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Apr 2008
                  • 62306
                  • 7,010
                  • 1,581
                  • 951,318

                  #18
                  Originally posted by IMDAZED
                  Cotto? Absolutely not. Clottey and Margarito? Absolutely yes.
                  clottey wasn't that bad.

                  he's a legit top 5 guy at 147.


                  marg was bad because he got totally mopped up in his last meaningful fight and had done nothing since.

                  at least clottey even though he lost to cotto can be argued he beat cotto and at minimum gave cotto a tough fight.

                  only thing that made clottey-pac fight look bad is clottey didn't show up.

                  Comment

                  • IMDAZED
                    Fair but Firm
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • May 2006
                    • 42644
                    • 1,134
                    • 1,770
                    • 67,152

                    #19
                    Originally posted by JonnyBlayze
                    and the better options were....?

                    berto? shane?
                    eh...
                    Mayweather over Clottey

                    Williams/Martinez/Berto over Margarito

                    Martinez/Bradley/Berto over Mosley

                    Comment

                    • IMDAZED
                      Fair but Firm
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • May 2006
                      • 42644
                      • 1,134
                      • 1,770
                      • 67,152

                      #20
                      Originally posted by Left Hook Tua
                      clottey wasn't that bad.

                      he's a legit top 5 guy at 147.


                      marg was bad because he got totally mopped up in his last meaningful fight and had done nothing since.

                      at least clottey even though he lost to cotto can be argued he beat cotto and at minimum gave cotto a tough fight.

                      only thing that made clottey-pac fight look bad is clottey didn't show up.
                      Clottey never shows up to a big fight. But you're right he wasn't bad. In fact, forget that Manny could've fought Floyd instead. Given the Cotto bout, Manny had every right to a tune-up. Except...he's now taking his third mediocre fight in a row, and got the fourth lined up (Cotto-Margarito winner).

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP