Who holds the better championship fight at 154?

[FloydTBE]

plues fight was at full 154lbs limit

[Bushbaby]

Cotto's fight wasn't meaningless,he went up in weight & defeated a champion in his rebound fight from being destroyed again!!

[Walt Liquor]

plues fight was at full 154lbs limit

well,

by the TS's logic, margarito already beat cotto, so beating margarito is more impressive than what cotto did

(in response to your santos crack about santos beating margs)

[infamous larryx]

but i give the edge to cotto cause he fought a real legit 154 pounder..at 154 for a legit belt...manny-margo was a circus event

[FloydTBE]

well,

by the TS's logic, margarito already beat cotto, so beating margarito is more impressive than what cotto did

(in response to your santos crack about santos beating margs)

Yeah. theres arguments for both guys really, both did the job they were expected to do

[Chuckguy]

Cotto beat the worst belt holder in the division who had a bad knee. Manny beat unranked guy in the division for a vacant belt and asked for a catchweight



I will say neither

worst then a guy who wasnt a belt holder and didnt do anythying to earn shot at the belt
hjahahahaahha
ahhaha
wow
Cotto at least beat a champ
/thread

[pistol whip]

Foreman was already holding a legit belt and is a natural 154 pounder,

Alphabet Belts are meaningless no matter how you slice it and Margarito had a 17 pound weight advantage so kind makes your whole catchweight theory a moot point.

[pistol whip]

worst then a guy who wasnt a belt holder and didnt do anythying to earn shot at the belt
hjahahahaahha
ahhaha
wow
Cotto at least beat a champ
/thread

And what exactly did Cotto do to earn his title shot at Forman? Get his face turned into hamburger?

[pistol whip]

but i give the edge to cotto cause he fought a real legit 154 pounder..at 154 for a legit belt...manny-margo was a circus event

Ugh how does fighting someone who has the belt differ than fighting for a vacant title? Does the belt posess magical powers that make you faster and stronger??

[Phenom]

Cotto's fight wasn't meaningless,he went up in weight & defeated a champion in his rebound fight from being destroyed again!!

foreman was just a standing target for who style depends on his footwork and movement he was pretty much a punch bag for cotto. anytime he took a step hes knee gives out and had no power to keep Cotto off so I wont exactly say Cotto defeated Foreman



with that said Its not Cotto fault that he got hurt and Cotto deserved a easy fight in a division he never fought in after the year he had with Pac and Clottey