Re: Sergio Martinez: Back 2 Reality

[infamous larryx]

what do amateur fights have to do with being a p4p pro???

[infamous larryx]

i think this is bute or freddy roach....lol

[Russian Crushin]

I Dont think Sergio should be #3 for beating the #5 pound for pound fighter a year after losing to him

Pacal beat Dawson who was #5 P4P at the time and he is nowhere close to being ranked

At best i would put Martinez #4 behind JMM

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Lucia Bute with his great wins over.....


Ummm.......


Help me out here.....

A shot Edison Miranda?

[Toe Injury]

i agree with you that williams was overrated and martinez hasnt proven himself to be on the level of pacquaio/mayweather

but then again neither has mayweather really, since his "retirement" hes barely done anything except fight a guy he dwarfed and a guy who everyone was begging to retire 4 months later vs sergio mora

as for bute i think hes an amazing fighter, a slick southpaw who sees body openings, he's beautiful to watch but totally not in the top p4p mix because he just hasnt thrown himself in there with the best yet. He's with showtime where the best in his division (imo the best division in boxing right now) are, so in a year lets see.

its easy to make the case for wlad being top 3 p4p; he's very active, he's beaten 2 prime nearly-undefeated (chambers and peter) contenders this year, and he has superior title longevity to all of the above, but sadly p4p lists are 50% a popularity contest, and HW will be an unpopular division as long as big eastern euros rule it

[Who are you?]

Lucian Bute > Sergio Martinez
Gennady Golovkin > Sergio Martinez

Dmitry Pirog is prolly 50/50 with Martinez... Id favour Martinez but only just

[infamous larryx]

I Dont think Sergio should be #3 for beating the #5 pound for pound fighter a year after losing to him

Pacal beat Dawson who was #5 P4P at the time and he is nowhere close to being ranked

At best i would put Martinez #4 behind JMM

well martinez did beat the linear middleweight champ a fight before beating williams

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Martinez knocks him the **** out sonny jim you know it and so does everyone not swinging on Poochies jock. No offense to pooch as he is a great fighter but Martinez is also an excellent fighter with handspeed and power but also size..

Poochie has beaten big fighters sure but none as fast or skilled as Martinez..

[MOTHER DUCKER]

And in all honesty Carl Froch deserves p4p n1 if he knocks out the midget king this saturday..

[Las Vegas,]

Lucian Bute > Sergio Martinez

Yes because wins over a shot Miranda and a shot Joppy make him a top 3 P4P! REALLY! IT DOES! Lmao.