does martinez become p4p #1 by beating wifebeater?

[Pullcounter]

martinez wants to be p4p #1. obviously there's no one at 160 lbs that he beats that will put him above pac or floyd.

considering that pac is way too small (martinez himself has said this on multiple occasions), can martinez really become p4p #1 just by beating wifebeater?

I think if martinez does beat wifebeater, he does get credit because he's done something no one officially (some believe wifebeater lost to castillo) has done. however, wifebeater (who weighs around 160 lbs on fight night) will be the smaller man against martinez (who weight around 168 lbs on fight night), therefore I'm not sure I can put him automaticallly at p4p #1 just by beating wifebeater.

I think for martinez to overtake pac as p4p #1, he'll have to beat wifebeater, clean out 154 lbs (fight cotto, kirkland, angulo), clean out 160 lbs (at least fight sturm and pirog), and beat bute and the super six winner at 168 lbs.

if he does all that, I can definitely put him above pac.

[Pocket Dogs!]

IMO he does.

[infamous larryx]

if martinez beats floyd hes easily p4p#1..thats bigger than anything manny has EVER done

[infamous larryx]

martinez wants to be p4p #1. obviously there's no one at 160 lbs that he beats that will put him above pac or floyd.

considering that pac is way too small (martinez himself has said this on multiple occasions), can martinez really become p4p #1 just by beating wifebeater?

I think if martinez does beat wifebeater, he does get credit because he's done something no one officially (some believe wifebeater lost to castillo) has done. however, wifebeater (who weighs around 160 lbs on fight night) will be the smaller man against martinez (who weight around 168 lbs on fight night), therefore I'm not sure I can put him automaticallly at p4p #1 just by beating wifebeater.

I think for martinez to overtake pac as p4p #1, he'll have to beat wifebeater, clean out 154 lbs (fight cotto, kirkland, angulo), clean out 160 lbs (at least fight sturm and pirog), and beat bute and the super six winner at 168 lbs.

if he does all that, I can definitely put him above pac.

why the hell would he have to do all that??manny aint never cleaned out a division,hardly defended a belt and wins titles at catchweights...

[-MAKAVELLI-]

by beating up on a once-a-year fighting smaller guy?

[REMOVED SHARK 97]

Lol 1000%, YES!...

[ИATAS]

How about moving up in weight and beating lucient bute and andre ward/etc.? He could become #1 by taking bigger challenges then everyone else.

[REMOVED SHARK 97]

If Floyd were to beat Martinez he would become P4P#1 again.

[eli porter]

beating any two of mayweather, pirog, bute or ward and he's number 1. Just mayweather? possibly, depending on how he looked maybe.

[infamous larryx]

If Floyd were to beat Martinez he would become P4P#1 again.

definitly...............