Segio Martinez vs. RJJ (160 lbs version).. who you got?

[CarlosG815]

roy jones altho hes nowhere near a top 10 atg....

Or top 20 for that matter as I would like to see who is "nowhere near" who you rate in your top 10.

[HitmanHattonAY]

roy jones jr !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Nuurzhaelan]

RJJ without question. Sergio would probably give him a fight, but I don't think he would contend well with Roy's power or accuracy. IIRC, RJJ was down first and hard to Tarver. Sergio went down to a Williams punch who does not have a ton power. I think RJJ takes this handily.

Also, of course, RJJ's defense. Most of the time it was his legs and reflexes, but he knew how to fight inside too. Remember his fight versus Bryant Brannon? Dude came out and wailed on him and Roy just calmly deflected the assault until he could create some breathing room for himself. Then he clobbered Brannon.

[CarlosG815]

Can you name 10 better at 168? I would wager that you can not.

I'm sure that he can not. He is talking out of his ass because he believes that it is the common consensus that Jones is not top 10 ATG when in reality it could be easily justified to have in there, or even higher....

[Owlzfan84]

I think Sergio is a very good fighter, but the praise he's getting for avenging a close loss is getting a little extreme around here. Havent seen this much love and hype for a guy coming off a win since Kelly Pavlik.

He's good, but prime Roy Jones makes him look ****** in an easy late TKO win.

[Kagami Taiga]

Can you name 10 better at 168? I would wager that you can not.

he said top 10 atg. rjj isnt top 10 atg even if hes top 5 at 168.

[Kagami Taiga]

I'm sure that he can not. He is talking out of his ass because he believes that it is the common consensus that Jones is not top 10 ATG when in reality it could be easily justified to have in there, or even higher....

dude, shut up. i can give a **** ass about general consensus of ****. its not even hard to name 10 fighters better than roy jones jr. dont kid urself. just because he was an amazing talent doesnt mean there arent ppl whove accomplished a whole lot more than him in their careers.

[Proff Griff]

[QUOTE=DempseyRollin;9648321]he said top 10 atg. rjj isnt top 10 atg even if hes top 5 at 168.[/QUOTE]





Sir, there are not even 2 better fighters at 168 than Jones. I believe he's number 1 there. I don't understand your hesitation on this topic. If you believe there are fighters better at 168, name them. Don't just throw numbers out.


Jones is finished now but we can't judge him out of prime anymore than we judge Ali, Duran, Louis and what not out of prime.

[Kagami Taiga]

[QUOTE=Proff Griff;9648385]

he said top 10 atg. rjj isnt top 10 atg even if hes top 5 at 168.[/QUOTE]





Sir, there are not even 2 better fighters at 168 than Jones. In terms of talent and skill he's number 1 there. I don't understand your hesitation on this topic. If you believe there are fighters better at 168, name them. Don't just throw numbers out.


Jones is finished now but we can't judge him out of prime anymore than we judge Ali, Duran, Louis and what not out of prime.

once again i wasnt talking at all about 168 i was talking about atg. ur spweing numbers and u accuse me of??? go back to my first post and find a place where i said rjj wasnt top 10 at 168??? why am i even arguing with u??? u totally missed my argument and ur attacking me...grow up and learn some reading comprehension.

[CarlosG815]

[QUOTE=DempseyRollin;9648409]

once again i wasnt talking at all about 168 i was talking about atg. ur spweing numbers and u accuse me of??? go back to my first post and find a place where i said rjj wasnt top 10 at 168??? why am i even arguing with u??? u totally missed my argument and ur attacking me...grow up and learn some reading comprehension.

Please list your top 20 ATG list so we can see who is so much better than Jones since "It is so easy to do."