IS Sergio an ATG after beating Pavlik and Paul Williams

[Rome-By-Ko]

Nope but he is making a very strong case,and if I was a betting man I would put my money on him being a ATG and getting into the HOF..

[joelab75]

If Sergio went up in weight against a Froch , Ward, Abraham or a Kessler he'll be in the fight of his life...he may beat Kessler and Abraham on UD but Froch and Ward we'll show him a fight..Lou DiBella said on his twitter that he wont be going up in weight..he'll be staying the same or going down..thats why i used the big 154 fighter above as examples

he wont be going up in another division so how can he prove he is ATG if he is not willing to fight bigger and stronger guys and he doesnt like catch weight so how can he fight Pac and Floyd? Calling out FLoyd to fight him in his comfort zone seems so unfair. if he is really too good and some already consider him ATG why not fighting Manny or FLoyd in 151 lbs? i know he'd be weight drained so another option is why not going up in weights to prove he can be as good as Pac and FLoyd?

[joelab75]

as of this moment he is not even a hall of famer yet. Beating PW was great win for him but PW is not even a futur hall of famer. its just happen that his fans thought he was that good.

[SOPH~ REP.]

Your kidding right
who has pavlik beat and dont forget pwill jump what from( 147-154-160-168 supermiddle fight night) to even get a+ fight

[Kagami Taiga]

hes a long way and i dont think he has enough prime left so i doubt he'll be an atg. but hofer is possible.

[Verstyle]

In my opinion he is, he has done a lot in his career to deserve a top 20 stop on the ATG list.

[2501]

No one is an ATG without beating Josie Harris. No one.

[AnimalisticMeth]

No, not at all. He is great and top 3 P4P today but Sergio got to North America just a few years ago so he's only got to face top fighters for only a short amount of time.

[IronDanHamza]

Is he even a solid HOF yet? I mean, if he goves up to 168 and does damage there, 3 weight champion could become a legit HOF but ATG? He would need to alot in a short span of time.

[IIG]

An all time great? Not even close. Look at his resume.