Sergio Martinez should be ranked number 1 pound for pound

[Russian Crushin]

Martinez would be lucky to make #3

He is nowhere close to #1 or 2

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

So Julio Caesar Chavez Jr # 2 P4P?

nah, what about zsolt erdai?

[kenso]

sergio should be p4p #1? give me a break. how many people on his resume have you really even heard of?

i do think he should be p4p #3, and hes a FANTASTIC fighter - i really like the guy i hope he continues on the path hes going, but to say he should be p4p #1 is pure idiocy and seems like a pac-hating thread.

pacs resume:
barrera
morales
marquez
de la hoya
hatton
cotto
clottey
margarito

martinez:
williams
pavlik
cintron

not even remotely close at all

[Russian Crushin]

nah, what about zsolt erdai?

Lets not forget Paul Spadafora

45-0 baby

[Russian Crushin]

sergio should be p4p #1? give me a break. how many people on his resume have you really even heard of?

i do think he should be p4p #3, and hes a FANTASTIC fighter - i really like the guy i hope he continues on the path hes going, but to say he should be p4p #1 is pure idiocy and seems like a pac-hating thread.

pacs resume:
barrera
morales
marquez
de la hoya
hatton
cotto
clottey
margarito

martinez:
williams
pavlik
cintron

not even remotely close at all

Plus he lost and drew with 2 of them

[slickfox]

sergio should be p4p #1? give me a break. how many people on his resume have you really even heard of?

i do think he should be p4p #3, and hes a FANTASTIC fighter - i really like the guy i hope he continues on the path hes going, but to say he should be p4p #1 is pure idiocy and seems like a pac-hating thread.

pacs resume:
barrera
morales
marquez
de la hoya
hatton
cotto
clottey
margarito

martinez:
williams
pavlik
cintron

not even remotely close at all

pac resume has knockouts by 2 bums, a CLEAR loss to morales and 1-2 losses to marquez(everyone knows what went down was pure robbery). The only win worthy of admiration where his previous opponet hadnt just got clobbered is barrera

[Red Rebel]

No..! Coz, it should be;

1. Bradley
2. Martinez
3. Pacquiao

[-The Glove-]

2 impressive wins make you P4P champ nowadays? Hmm...

[nachorjj]

Im from argentina aand dont rank him in the top 5 p4p

[MXboxingfan]

2 impressive wins make you P4P champ nowadays? Hmm...

Martinez's last two wins are much more impressive than Pacquiao's last two wins.