How well would Manny do vs a prime Tito, Oscar, Shane at 147?

[rickyisgood]

People are overating him right now cuz beating a slow moving punching bag is considered a huge win.

[joelab75]

3 years ago Manny would lose by a MURDER against Dela Hoya, Cotto, CLottey and Margarito. but in reality Manny beat and DESTROY those guys. They had the beating of their lives. of course Manny would lose to Tito and Dela Hoya in their prime. its a fantasy fight. but in reality Manny would do the same to them.

[wylout]

well considering the fact that manny would have been in his prime too, i say the same results

[Rome-By-Ko]

DLH got tagged a lot by the limited Mago Gonzales and faded late in that fight, his fight against John John Molina he also got tagged a lot. Lets not forget a lot of people felt the old Whittaker who barely beat Hurtado from a come from behind stoppage and got 2 gifts imo against Rivera deserved the decision. Lets not forget Darrell Coley had DLH stunned in a round I forget which.

Trinidad looked plenty vulnerable at 147, he got dropped by plenty fighters like Carr/Campas/Cortes/Stephens. He beat Blocker/Campas/Camacho then didn't fight anyone of note for about 4 years until beating Whittaker. He then got the gift against Oscar while looking like a mummy because of Oscar's fast feet.

The welterweights from the late 90's were great but they weren't unbeatable, I don't see them being 2 levels above Cotto/Floyd/Pac/Marg(pre-shane).

BTW If u don't think Pac could hurt Trinidad look what the southpaw Cortes did to him in round two.

http://www.**********.com/?d=JTDRZ8OP

1.Hoya had one of the best jabs in the sport,he also had very good footwork..I agree he does get tired but Hoya had a great chin and would have lasted with Pac in his prime and beat Pac imo to many weapons..

2.Tito was hurt in about damn near every fight the man has ever had..It's always been what he does after he is hurt that's been his legacy..Tito I feel you are underrating him and his boxing ability..

3.Cotto Marga's Berto and Clottey all would not be even known back in the WW era of the 90's(well maybe Cotto)none of them do anything great they are decent fighters..Mosley Hoya,Tito were on manny's level in talent and stardom Manny is a great so I would give him a chance with these dogz in their prime but I really do believe Cotto Berto and Marga's all get their asses handed to umm..

[fitefan]

to put it in simple terms.......

......he loses to them all in exciting fashion

oscar would've really ****ed him up

[Rome-By-Ko]

also pacquaio is in his prime now and has been for the last few years right? exactly who has he beaten that a prime trinidad, de la hoya, mosley wouldnt beat? clottey? cotto - post margarito? margarito - post shane mosley? why doesnt he fight guys who are on top why do they all have to have suffered a recent savage beating? hatton from mayweather, cotto from margarito, margarito from shane mosley, de la hoya believe it or not lost something when he fought mayweather because in his very next fight steve forbes hurt him a bit and busted his face up almost as bad as pacquaio did

Spot on with both ya post...

[Hallaqsillaq]

3 years ago Manny would lose by a MURDER against Dela Hoya, Cotto, CLottey and Margarito. but in reality Manny beat and DESTROY those guys. They had the beating of their lives. of course Manny would lose to Tito and Dela Hoya in their prime. its a fantasy fight. but in reality Manny would do the same to them.

Did you see how damaged he was after the Cotto fight? And Cotto barely landed anything other than some jabs. Tito had mean, heavy hands man, plus he was a taller fighter.

It's nothing against Pac, those guys were just near, at, or above his level at WW. Not p4p, WW. Tossup fights.

[rickyisgood]

the fights would be excited all 4 of them hav speed and power...........

[T.Horton]

Oscar had a great jab and left hook and he would trouble Manny for the first half of the fight. I would guess Pacquiao would take a decision against a prime de la Hoya.

Trinidad - it would be a war. Tito had crazy power and he was a big, BIG, welter weight. I think he knocks Manny out.

Mosley - this would be a war. Fight of the decade type of fight. Both can move (though Manny is like a damned jumping bean on speed) and Shane has been known to gas late. I would go out on a limb and say Manny narrowly beats him though I am hesitant in saying this.

[rickyisgood]

Again whos has Manny beaten anyone close to the fab 3?