When Manny beat Oscar a couple years ago, this question would be laughed at. Not so funny anymore IMO. Seeing how easily Manny has dominated the best fighters today between 135 - 150lbs, I now wonder how well he would have done against the Tito and Oscar that fought each other. Or against the Shane and Oscar who fought each other the first time. What you all think?
ktfo by all of them.
his best chance is against oscar who had problems with southpaws and wasn't as physical as shane and tito.
Manny would beat Tito and Mosley at 147. Manny would get beaten by Oscar at 147.
Tito isn't slick enough. It has been proven time and time again that ANYBODY with good footwork can outsmart Felix. Prime Shane would likely KO Manny at LIGHTWEIGHT, but Mosley hasn't been prime since he moved up. Don't get me wrong, he's put on some brilliant performances at higher weights, but wasn't his KO % like 80 at lightweight?
Prime Oscar at 147 is a different story. I think a jabbing oscar and a body punching Oscar would be too much for Manny at 147. We saw what effect Margarito's body shots had on Manny, I think Oscar would likely KO him.
IMHO the Shane that fought Oscar would likely KO Pac or at least hurt him a few times on his way to victory,I would not say not prime but your right he was his strongest at 135lb...
Tweet
Comment