How well would Manny do vs a prime Tito, Oscar, Shane at 147?

[El Chicano]

When Manny beat Oscar a couple years ago, this question would be laughed at. Not so funny anymore IMO. Seeing how easily Manny has dominated the best fighters today between 135 - 150lbs, I now wonder how well he would have done against the Tito and Oscar that fought each other. Or against the Shane and Oscar who fought each other the first time. What you all think?

[PEBBLES!]

All those fighters KO Pacroid within 3 rounds in their prime at 147.

[R.M {7}]

Manny is too fast for Oscar. Manny will blow him away.

Shane has the power - But the work rate of Pac, the footwork and speed will beat him by UD.

Tito beats him..

[jiraiyasama]

In Fantasy Fights they will KO PAC..

In Reality Fights, Pac put them to sleep. Tito, Oscar and Shane are not on the same league with Pacquiao...

[El Chicano]

Manny is too fast for Oscar. Manny will blow him away.

Shane has the power - But the work rate of Pac, the footwork and speed will beat him by UD.

Tito beats him..

Oscar made Tito look like an amatuer... Manny would probably make him look worse. And with Tito's tendency to go down early, the fight would probably be a short one.

[R.M {7}]

That's why I put the .....pic

[PEBBLES!]

Oscar made Tito look like an amatuer... Manny would probably make him look worse. And with Tito's tendency to go down early, the fight would probably be a short one.

Tito's power + Manny's suspect chin = Certain Decapitation.

[RockyB]

Oscar made Tito look like an amatuer... Manny would probably make him look worse. And with Tito's tendency to go down early, the fight would probably be a short one.

This is what i think too. Titos chin is not strong enough.
Oscar would probably loose, but be more competitive than 08 Oscar.

and Shane only has a punchers chance IMO.

[RockyB]

Tito's power + Manny's suspect chin = Certain Decapitation.

What about Titos chin/tendency to go down early + Mannys extreme workrate and above decent power?

[PEBBLES!]

What about Titos chin/tendency to go down early + Mannys extreme workrate and above decent power?

His workrate means little if the fight ends early, which it will vs Tito.

Tito has an underrated chin and the heart of a lion. If he goes down early, it will only increase the chances of decapitation - Tito always made his opponents pay.