posters on here argued with me last night that shane,margo had better resumes than

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Well Oscar was high in the P4P list also. And, was favorite to destroy Shane who many felt was too small coming up from LW and skipping 140.

So what is your point?

That version of Oscar>Corrales. Not taking away anything from Floyd win over Corrales cuz it was a great win. But, if you look at Oscar resume up to that point with Corrales is a no contest. Plus Oscar was in his prime. And, a sure fire HOF'er.

The Oscar win>The Corrales win.

However, overall body of work of Floyd>Shane. Just that Shane the better win.

plus Oscar didnt have a jail term hanging over his head like Chico did.

[jrosales13]

whitaker did'nt get rob vs oscar....he ran most of the fight showboating, he did'nt do squat !

A past prime Whitaker made a prime Oscar look silly at times.

[Left Hook Tua]

Mosley and Oscar were both part of that though so how does that effect their resume, also that shit ended with Floyd

i don't get it.

they were before the mayorga , spinks , judah , baldomir garbage.

[CBR1000RR]

neither have a case, but shane would be the closest.

[The Gambler1981]

i don't get it.

they were before the mayorga , spinks , judah , baldomir garbage.

Tito, then it ended and started with Oscar-Mosley,Forrest,Mayorga, Spinks, Judah, Baldomir, Floyd.

Out of all those guys on the list Floyd had the best run as the champion because all the other guys had no run what so ever to speak of.

[jrosales13]

Tito, then it ended and started with Oscar-Mosley,Forrest,Mayorga, Spinks, Judah, Baldomir, Floyd.

Out of all those guys on the list Floyd had the best run as the champion because all the other guys had no run what so ever to speak of.

That is because neither wanted to give Marg a shot.

True story.

He had to wait all the way to 2008

Anyways Marg is arguably the best WW in the last era. Granted the last era is weak. It was not the 90's WW era let alone the 80's WW era. But, it was still an era that Marg has a case to being the best in.

[RubenSonny]

A past prime Whitaker made a prime Oscar look silly at times.

Oscar trying to go southpaw and getting knocked down

[The Gambler1981]

That is because neither wanted to give Marg a shot.

True story.

He had to wait all the way to 2008

Anyways Marg is arguably the best WW in the last era. Granted the last era is weak. It was not the 90's WW era let alone the 80's WW era. But, it was still an era that Marg has a case to being the best in.

If you can't become the champ in a weak era that is a pretty bad mark on a fighters career.

If you fight in a weak era you better be winning like the Klitschko's are, if you are great fighting spotty opposition that is what it should look like.

[RubenSonny]

Floyds win over Castillo is his greatest win and its almost as good as Mosleys win over DLH.

[The Gambler1981]

Also out of the champions I listed I would say margarito could have fucked with maybe three. Baldomir and Mayorga coule have been had and depending on how Spinks fight that is also a possibility.

The rest would have been tough for Margarito.