is johnny tapia an atg??

[JAB5239]

HOF yes maybe ATG Great ameatur career and pro is was just as good the pualie fight kill him on the atg but Never know

I don't think so. Both were close, great fights. Its not like he lost to some bum.

[IMDAZED]

God bless Johnny, who I had the pleasure to chat with 12 years ago at my local supermarket. That said..he's not close to being an ATG.

[Kagami Taiga]

I don't think so. Both were close, great fights. Its not like he lost to some bum.

like i said ppl really underrate ayala. the guy was one of the top mexican(american) fighters of his day. the ppl he lost to were all top fighters.

[Swag Hustla]

I loved watching Tapia fight.

Very exciting fighter, but the term ATG has been thrown around a little too loosely these days.

Hall of Famer for sure though.

[Chaconlittlered]

I don't think so. Both were close, great fights. Its not like he lost to some bum.

I'm not saying pualie is a bum just to be an atg he should of beat him to be considered an atg

[Sweet Jesus]

If it was up to BoxingScene, the ATG list would have about 300 fighters on it.

Let's try to develop some exclusivity guys.

[infamous larryx]

I'm not saying pualie is a bum just to be an atg he should of beat him to be considered an atg

is manny an atg??he lost to 2 nobodies

is ali an atg??he lost to a guy with 8 fights

[MACAQUEINBLACK]

I'd say he'd have to belong to that throng of fighters just outside the ATG list. Upper-tier HOF, in other words.

[Sweet Jesus]

is manny an atg??he lost to 2 nobodies

is ali an atg??he lost to a guy with 8 fights

Joe Calzaghe never lost. He's nowhere near an ATG.

[infamous larryx]

Joe Calzaghe never lost. He's nowhere near an ATG.

imo if hopkins is an atg..calzaghe damn sure is