Floyd is "talented" but is he an ATG?

[infamous larryx]

Yes...he ...is ...an ....atg...common...sense

[djtmal]

he's about to hit the past prime mark, so these next few fights will tell the real story.....

[THE REED]

Try being a boxing fan for once.

[V.WEBB]

Yes...he ...is ...an ....atg...common...sense

Common sense isn't common.

Try being a boxing fan for once.

Its impossible.

[Boss Don]

how is Floyd not a ATG???

A 6 time world champion in 5 diffrent weight classes in under 10 years and never took a loss who else done it like that you tell me?

[jrosales13]

Of course he is.

IMO top 50 ATG, at the very least he is clearly in the top 75. Even being in the top 75 is no disrespect if you see how many great fighters can't make the top 75.

IMO in the top 3 all time at SFW, I have him #2. Very easily in the top 5 in a division that has a rich history.

So to say or suggest that he isn't an ATG is just ridiculous

[JOM'S]

he is def ATG, not the GOAT but ATG top 100 for sure ....

[Kagami Taiga]

u guys expose urself when u write topics like this. saying floyd is a ducker, ok. saying floyd is an *******, maybe true. saying floyd isnt the best fighter is def true. but to say he isnt an atg, u have to come up with at least 100 fighters who have accomplished the **** he has. i guarantee u that u wont. u guys think the **** he does is easy against bum competition. i kno u guys hate when ppl mention his record but the guy has nearly won every damn round of boxing he has ever fought in his career! he has yet to really lose a fight even tho he's been in the ring with some good talent. that itself is quite amazing not to mention the championships in 5 weight classes(how many fighters have done that?? u *******s think its easy). the guy is an atg, i doubt if even dan rafael would argue different.

[IMDAZED]

For a long time I was hesitant to call him that. A great fighter? Yes. A HOF'er? Yes. But ATG? I think at this point...yes. May 1st changed my mind.

[MiguelDirrell25]

Whoever floyd fights it kinda leaves something to be desired by fans , when he beats the likes of Hatton ,DLH , etc . And comes out unscaved fans think it wasn't a challenge , but truth is he is so much better than who he gets in the ring with its pretty boring for us fans to watch.

Fans like adversity ,a fighter showing his heart and mettle , coming off the canvas to pull off a epic KO.
These are the things floyd doesn't do , he's a cautious defense first fighter , he rarely opens up aside from maybe the gatti fight.

In this case I say NO he is not Atg fighter

I need to see a challenge , where's the Cotto,Margarito,Cintron,P.williams,Pac,Clottey
When he steps up and face these type of fighters regardless of outcome then we can have this discussion.