Floyd is "talented" but is he an ATG?

[IronDanHamza]

Whoever floyd fights it kinda leaves something to be desired by fans , when he beats the likes of Hatton ,DLH , etc . And comes out unscaved fans think it wasn't a challenge , but truth is he is so much better than who he gets in the ring with its pretty boring for us fans to watch.

Fans like adversity ,a fighter showing his heart and mettle , coming off the canvas to pull off a epic KO.
These are the things floyd doesn't do , he's a cautious defense first fighter , he rarely opens up aside from maybe the gatti fight.

In this case I say NO he is not Atg fighter

I need to see a challenge , where's the Cotto,Margarito,Cintron,P.williams,Pac,Clottey
When he steps up and face these type of fighters regardless of outcome then we can have this discussion.

He fought Shane Mosley, a guy who regardless to his age, was a bigger threat than anyone on that list at that particular time other than Pacqiauo, Period. Give a dude his props man.

[MiguelDirrell25]

He fought Shane Mosley, a guy who regardless to his age, was a bigger threat than anyone on that list at that particular time other than Pacqiauo, Period. Give a dude his props man.

I didn't take anything away from his wins ,like I said he is much better than most of his opposition.
Everyone knows shane is no where near his prime as a fighter , nonetheless I thought shane would win,
Which goes to show you floyd is at his best and will be a tough fight for anyone from 147-154

When his cat like reflexes start to diminish ,that's when floyd will probably show the true fighter in him because he will be forced to fight and ; at the end of the day isn't that what we all want