calzaghe would destroy everyone in the current SMM division

[Spray_resistant]

I would have Joe over them all, especially AA who he would make look like another Lacy in the ring.

[THE REED]

And prime Roy beats them all and Joe

[-EX-]

Destroy?

I didn't see much of Joe until he got older...I think Dirrell would make it an ugly fight and Ward and Abraham could give Joe some problems...

[slicksouthpaw16]

He could decision Froch in a tough fight but Ward and Direll's style would give him fits. Abraham also has a big punchers chance.

[MiguelDirrell25]

Imo calzahge or however u spell dat shid is not really dat good wen he was fighting at 168 there was no 1 der to fight really , his best win was against kessler, other then that he's fought no one that was good in their prime so calzage is not even considered an atg and would not beat anyone in the 168 division but frochh maybe , Dirrell ,ward,bute,AA all gives him da business

[Phenom]

Ward is a broke ass version of Hopkins who Calzaghe pwned. He would get destroyed worse than Lacy.



Froch might give him some problems cuz' of his power, but overall yeah, Joe Cokezaghe would own them all imo.

Ur stoopid.

how ironic

[americanbot]

some people are ******ed.

in my opinion a old hopkins beat calzaghe. at this point ward fights like a old hopkins but BETTER. i would take ward over joe in that one.

dirrell is a tough toss up...

froch....

i see froch giving joe problems but joe should win the ud. i wouldn't be shocked if froch beat him though.

i give abraham a VERY good punchers chance.....


this is A LOT more realistic then the fantasies that have been spewed in this thread .....

[oaklandstephen]

He beats all of them except Andre Ward.

and dirrell

[-Antonio-]

Everyone but Ward.

[BEEHOP]

Andre Ward