If Khan beats Maidana he is > Hatton

[S.G.]

No, not quite. But you're right, he won't be far off. If he beats Maidana and then Ortiz or the winner of Bradley-Alexander afterwards I'd put his CV ahead of Hatton's.

[the_ilest]

naw, hatton was champ in two weight divisions. while, khan got smashed at 135 and moved up 140 and became a champ.

[DrewWoodside]

Tzsyu shot is better than Kotelnik. And I think that Tyzsu is a bad style for Khan

Not to mention that Hatton would beat Kotelnik. Not saying Kotelnik isn't very good, but stylistically I'd pick Hatton to take a decision over Kotelnik as well for sure.

[Boxin']

You forgot to mention Prescott.

[the_ilest]

yeah, poor prescott he beat khan and is less famous now.

[Pullcounter]

Some might argue he allready is, I mean Hatton had a terrible resume, heres his best wins

Urango (Urango is garbage and so was this fight)
Collazo (Collazo actually won this fight)
Tzsyu (was so shot it's not even funny)
Maglinaggi (It's Maglinaggi)
Castillo (during his ringwalk the commentators proclaimed him a shot fighter)

Khans best wins

Kotelnik (this guy is better than anyone hatton beat, YES IM SERIOUS, khan also shut him out)
Maglinaggi (Same as Hatton, but khan beat him better)
Barerra (old and small, but probably equal to castillo in terms of what he offered)

Add Maidana to that list and Khan unquestionably surpasses Hatton.

tszyu is better than anyone khan has fought.

also, hatton only got KTFO by 2 of the best of this era... khan got KTFO by presscott.

c'mon guy.

[S.G.]

tszyu is better than anyone khan has fought.

also, hatton only got KTFO by 2 of the best of this era... khan got KTFO by presscott.

c'mon guy.

Just 'cos they were the only ones to do it doesn't mean they are the only ones that could...

[Bushbaby]

Sure because Maidana is greater than Kosta Tsu right??

[ma51f]

Earl isn't much of a Hatton fan, I don't think he likes his style. A prime Hatton kills Khan, in fact, if/when he gets himself together I still think he beats him. That said, Khan has talent, he just needs to box to his strengths and avoid his weaknesses like the plague.

khan isnt even in his prime yet he'd still beat prime hatton

as Freddie said, for a world champion he just wasnt that good

[bruzza]

Too many arguments on here but failing one.

When khan was knocked out, what were the crowd singing?

When hatton got knocked out, what were the crowd singing?

Even mayweather was astounded.

Khan has yet to discover greatness. FACT!!!