Who hits Harder? Manny, Miguel or Shane?

[tocayito1]

I'm assuming by KO you mean either knocking his opponent unconscious, or being damaged by one punch to the point to where his opponent could not make referee's count. If I'm not mistaking Shane still holds the highest KO percentage of any lightweight with at least 20 fights or something.


Ricardo Mayorga, Adrian Stone, Wilfredo Rivera, Golden Johnson, Wilfredo Ruiz, Manuel Gomez, Michael Smith, Elias Quiroz, Mauricio Aceyes, Raul Hernandez, Jose Luis Madrid, John Bryant, Lorenzo Garcia, Francisco Rodriguez, Paulino Gonzalez, Juan Manuel Aranda, Miguel Pena, Roberto Urias, Pey Castillo, Arunulfo Villa, and finally Greg Puente.


I understand you are probably thinking to yourself "Wait a minute, I thought we were just talking about one-punch KO power?" Indeed, with all those stats it's hard to determine which fights were ended as a direct result to power alone or just volume. The last person Shane KO'd with a power shot was Mayorga, although it can be argued that it was one great shot that put Cheato on ***** street but I don't count that because he kept getting up until ref waived it off. Who was the last person Manny Pacquiao rendered an opponent unable to continue as a direct result of power from a single blow?

ricky hatton

[El Chicano]

your analytical discussion wouldn't be trying to propose that Manny(not you, but the one you worship) is the harder puncher...right?

See my vote.

[ralph22]

mannnys ped are very effective

[El Chicano]

Whoops I forgot to answer the question. Shane hits WAY harder than any of these men. In fact I think Mosley's power is comparable to that of Trinidad.

I don't even wish to try to compare Pac and Margarito as neither are one punch KO artists, and both are not power punchers but indeed VOLUME PUNCHERS

See Manny Pacquiao vs Ricky Hatton. Shane does not hit as hard as Tito.

[check hook]

Some stats (though i don't not consider them difinitive) ---->despite what some people on here like to claim...numbers can and indeed do LIE!!!!!!


SSM: 54 fights for a KO% of 72.22%

Cotto: 37 fights for a KO% of 75.68%

Pac: 56 fights for a KO% of 67.86%

[Gorilla Dogs]

ive seen interviews with a fighter that sparred all of em and he said shane has most power by far.

[El Chicano]

Shane caught Miguel with some pretty good shots, why then was he never really able to get Miguel into any real trouble, while Tony and Manny were able to hurt him?

[Gorilla Dogs]

Some stats (though i don't not consider them difinitive) ---->despite what some people on here like to claim...numbers can and indeed do LIE!!!!!!


SSM: 54 fights for a KO% of 72.22%

Cotto: 37 fights for a KO% of 75.68%

Pac: 56 fights for a KO% of 67.86%

Tyrone Brunson has a KO% 86.96


does that make em a harder puncher than SSM?



gtfoh........tyrone brunson is the biggest fraud in the history of boxing FTW

[tocayito1]

Shane caught Miguel with some pretty good shots, why then was he never really able to get Miguel into any real trouble, while Tony and Manny were able to hurt him?

simple tony had bricks and manny is on peds

[Franco2012]

Mosley is weakest puncher of 3.

He couldnt even KO that bum Estrada and Cruz.

Even light puncha Clottey knocked Cruz out cold.