Is it fair to say JMM is a bum above 140bs?

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Twiggy
    Amateur
    • May 2010
    • 22
    • 9
    • 5
    • 6,038

    #31
    Originally posted by PittyPat
    Bum, no. That's a hugely insulting word that should only be reserved for awful fighters (if even that). However, he isn't all that great at 135. People may come to realise this in November...
    You think Katsidis will show us that JMM isn't "all that great"?

    JMM is elite LW in todays competition, and was elite FW and SFW by any standards. As much as I like Katsidis, he is really not in Marquez' league.

    Comment

    • goldenglove2
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Oct 2008
      • 2763
      • 54
      • 8
      • 8,954

      #32
      Originally posted by BillyBoxing
      Style wise,I would give him a chance to beat Berto.

      Berto couldn't ko Urango,has a suspect jaw and is a gift for counter punching.
      Berto would own, stop JMM at 147....

      Comment

      • PittyPat
        Kin yer taste the blood?!
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • Jan 2009
        • 11183
        • 696
        • 439
        • 28,773

        #33
        Originally posted by Twiggy
        You think Katsidis will show us that JMM isn't "all that great"?
        Now, don't get it twisted - I said Marquez isn't all that great at 135. Obviously he's great otherwise, but it's perfectly possible that Kats will show Marquez's age. Just look at the success Diaz had in the first fight - he made Marquez look old and flustered.

        Originally posted by Twiggy
        JMM is elite LW in todays competition, and was elite FW and SFW by any standards. As much as I like Katsidis, he is really not in Marquez' league.
        We'll see. He's only had 3 fights at the weight, and the first 2 of those were extremely difficult outings for him (the scorecards before the stoppages reflect that). His best days were at 126 and, to a lesser extent, 130.

        Comment

        • ROSS CALIFORNIA
          Tyson fan
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Oct 2007
          • 69864
          • 997
          • 1,956
          • 113,453

          #34
          Originally posted by SmoothMon
          I rewatched the Floyd fight, and I think he's just as fast or slow as he's always been. it seemed like a bad style matchup to me. I doubt it would have made a difference if they fought a few lbs lighter. He just couldnt get off...it happens. Is it fair?
          Floyd is just a bad ass MF anyway, thats why Juan looked bad.

          Comment

          • Twiggy
            Amateur
            • May 2010
            • 22
            • 9
            • 5
            • 6,038

            #35
            Originally posted by PittyPat
            Now, don't get it twisted - I said Marquez isn't all that great at 135. Obviously he's great otherwise, but it's perfectly possible that Kats will show Marquez's age. Just look at the success Diaz had in the first fight - he made Marquez look old and flustered.
            Didn't want to twist, was just asking. Thing is, age can slow down JMM some and take away some reflexes, but it cannot annull his style. He is one of the best counter punchers in sport and has a great chin and decent power at LW. Besides that, he was never KOed and is always in tip top shape. Katsidis is stronger and bigger than him and he will cause him trouble till JMM figures him out and then is only inevitable.

            On the other hand, every fighter comes to night when he grows old. Casa was also never KOed till JMM came.

            We'll see. He's only had 3 fights at the weight, and the first 2 of those were extremely difficult outings for him (the scorecards before the stoppages reflect that).
            Ok, we'll see. I just don't think Kats has power enough to stop JMM and he ceartanly doesn't have the skill to outpoint him. But, like I said, father time always comes, sooner for some, later for others, so we'll have to wait.
            Last edited by Twiggy; 09-06-2010, 09:34 AM.

            Comment

            • goldenglove2
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Oct 2008
              • 2763
              • 54
              • 8
              • 8,954

              #36
              Originally posted by RossCA
              Floyd is just a bad ass MF anyway, thats why Juan looked bad.
              also JMM was fighting two weight classes higher than he should have been. Floyd is such cherry picker!

              Comment

              • Jim Jeffries
                rugged individualist
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Oct 2007
                • 20741
                • 1,376
                • 2,868
                • 54,838

                #37
                No, Floyd is just that good. But JMM is an aging fighter that is most effective at 135 lbs and shouldn't be fighting at 140, nevermind above that.

                Comment

                • PittyPat
                  Kin yer taste the blood?!
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • Jan 2009
                  • 11183
                  • 696
                  • 439
                  • 28,773

                  #38
                  Originally posted by Twiggy
                  Didn't want to twist, was just asking.
                  No worries.

                  Originally posted by Twiggy
                  Thing is, age can slow down JMM some and take away some reflexes, but it cannot annull his style. He is one of the best counter punchers in sport and has a great chin and decent power at LW. Besides that, he was never KOed and is always in tip top shape. Katsidis is stronger and bigger than him and he will cause him trouble till JMM figures him out and then is only inevitable.
                  The bold is exactly what Kats will look to do - nullify that superior skillset by charging in, applying relentless pressure (i.e Diaz 1) and not giving Marquez the chance to get his usual counterpunching rhythm going. A good example of Marquez needing some time to get into said rhythm is the first Pacquiao fight. Granted, he dominated Pacquiao after round 2, but that was when the latter was stylistically a wild, crazy lunatic.

                  My point is that Kats is capable of repeating that same kind of round 1 as the Pacquaio fight - i.e. scoring flash KDs and forcing him on the defensive back foot - but it's up to him to finish Marquez when he has him in that kind position because, as you said, it'll only be a matter of time before he gets his rhythm going and outboxes Kats for the rest of the way.

                  Also, I obviously realise Marquez is not an Escobedo who'll let Kats bully him around for 12 rounds (then again, Diaz did it in the first fight...) He's smarter than that, and Kats knows it. Thus, his only option is to stop him early like he did with Mitchell. There's no way Kats can decision Marquez convincingly. He'd be extremely lucky to get even an SD.

                  My message to Kats would be - swarm with your guard up like you've never swarmed before, and don't try to outbox the fella! We've got this.

                  Comment

                  • Ido
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jan 2009
                    • 1454
                    • 24
                    • 7
                    • 7,670

                    #39
                    I reffuse to call JMM a bum, regardless of his performance in the 147 division.

                    Comment

                    • Ido
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                      • Jan 2009
                      • 1454
                      • 24
                      • 7
                      • 7,670

                      #40
                      Looking forward to the JMM-Kats fight. I see JMM outboxing Kats. But the skin over JMM left eyebrow worries me. Having been in sooo many wars, its prone to swelling/cuts.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP