Is it fair to say JMM is a bum above 140bs?

[TOBYLEE1]

He has the skills but not the natural physical size to stay competitive. To call him a bum is not the right choice of word. On top of that it was against a naturally skilled foe and one of the top p4p fighter. In going win which so many disadvantage he at least kept trying and didn't get KOed

[Ryannn]

haha, people are judging marquez on one fight he had at 147lbs. His opponent made him look bad, the same opponent has made many fighters look awful.

how else should we judge marquez as a welterweight?

of course we're gonna base it on the one fight he had there

so cause he lost to floyd, (winning no rounds, no less) that means he would beat everyone at 147?

man, you should get your head checked.

[goldenglove2]

haha, people are judging marquez on one fight he had at 147lbs. His opponent made him look bad, the same opponent has made many fighters look awful.

Floyd was off for two years.....

Why isnt JMM campaining at 147? simple......use logic.

[FloydTBE]

how else should we judge marquez as a welterweight?

of course we're gonna base it on the one fight he had there

so cause he lost to floyd, (winning no rounds, no less) that means he would beat everyone at 147?

man, you should get your head checked.

It doesnt mean hes gunna beat everyone and also ot doesnt mean that hes gunna lsoe to everyone. The way you are talking, JMM would get KOd by every one above 140lbs

[jrosales13]

haha, people are judging marquez on one fight he had at 147lbs. His opponent made him look bad, the same opponent has made many fighters look awful.

And, you judging him as a WW watching what exatly? His SFW fights?

And, no I am not judging him in his one WW fight even though he looked slow, powerless, and with no legs. That is not actually cuz of the opponent.

I am actually judging him by what he looks at 135. If you see at 135 it looks like how at times he gets bullied in there, how he doesn't have his freakin legs and that is what 135. Main reason is that is his limit, he can't go higher than that and still be effective. Are you really that dumb that you can't see it?

[-Huey-]

I rewatched the Floyd fight, and I think he's just as fast or slow as he's always been. it seemed like a bad style matchup to me. I doubt it would have made a difference if they fought a few lbs lighter. He just couldnt get off...it happens. Is it fair?

You're the bum, ****!.....Red k sent

[shade darkar]

anyone who thinks marquez is a bum doesnt know shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit!

[FloydTBE]

anyone who thinks marquez is a bum doesnt know shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit!

I second that

[BillyBoxing]

I rewatched the Floyd fight, and I think he's just as fast or slow as he's always been. it seemed like a bad style matchup to me. I doubt it would have made a difference if they fought a few lbs lighter. He just couldnt get off...it happens. Is it fair?

He was more flat footed than the 130 Marquez.

Marquez couldn't hurt Floyd and Floyd could hurt Marquez.
Floyd was obviously bigger and stronger and it helps you to beat a smaller guy.

The size was a factor,I'm not saying Marquez would have beat Floyd at 130,I'm just saying he had no crack at 146.
Being weaker and lighter than Floyd,the guy wasn't going to put a Duran vs Barkley simply because Floyd ain't as hittable as Iran Barkley by miles,and as much as I like JMM he isn't a beast like Duran was.

When a guy jump 2 divisions,it means nothing P4P wise.

[BillyBoxing]

He wouldn't beat anyone in the top 10 at 147 IMO.

Style wise,I would give him a chance to beat Berto.

Berto couldn't ko Urango,has a suspect jaw and is a gift for counter punching.