Which Win Is Better? Floyd Over Oscar Or Pacquiao Over Margarito?

[jrosales13]

Then Kotelink is the better win if he's the better fighter, Alexander is not supposed to have an easy time with him if he's the better fighter. Again you turned something simple and made it overly, nonsensibly, and aggregatively complex which isnt the intent. But we know why you did this, because the answer is clear and its not your man.

How the **** getting a gift decision over the other winning damn near every round in a new weight-class be considered a better win?

Yea he fought the better but he lost to the better fighter and got a gift hometown cooking decision. That fails for win is a win.

You so idiotic is not even funny. And, no is not cuz is not "clearly my man" I thought that version of Oscar was done. I gave him zero shot. At that time I was naming 5 other JWW and a couple other WWs who I felt could beat him. That is how done I thought Oscar was. Margarito is still a question mark to me. I need to see him first and that is why this question can not be answer right now Idiot.

But, it is like Handspeed said if you mean which one is more legit. Then OK that is a different type of question.

A win is a win GTFOH.

[Russian Crushin]

I know that is why you asked the question, but maybe you should have worded the title differently.

Like: What fight is more legit to you? Oscar/Floyd at 154(for a title) or Pac/Margo at 150(for a title)...Not sure that would have all fit, but you see what I'm saying.

Oh so this is a catchweight question

[HandSpeed303]

Anybody who has followed the situation I was hoping would take all of that into consideration. I noticed when the simple answer is Floyd on polls and topics, the question being asked is dissected apart to forfeit in giving an answer, cant believe people hate that dude that much.

I know me and you don't see eye to eye on much, but I do understand the question.

For The Record: I would say Floyd...Cause it was at 154.

[HandSpeed303]

Oh so this is a catchweight question

Of course it is.

[GrandpaBernard]

marg is a nobody compared to Oscar

[Elotero]

So a win over David Diaz==a win over Cotto?

Get real dude and stop nut hugging

No, a win over Jorge Solis = a win over Cotto.

Nuthugger ass thread.

[Pullcounter]

Which win is better between these two?

this is kinda a ****** question. oscar is a bonafide HOFer. Margarito doesn't have that kind of credentials.

but I guarantee marg/pac will be a lot more exciting than floyd/dlh.

[pasawayako]

If Pac wins against marg = floyd win against diego corrales.

[Russian Crushin]

this is kinda a ****** question. oscar is a bonafide HOFer. Margarito doesn't have that kind of credentials.

but I guarantee marg/pac will be a lot more exciting than floyd/dlh.

Pac vs speedbag is more exciting then that

[GoogleMe]

I can tell u which is the better win based off the circumstances. Oscar was a titleholder when Floyd fought him at the full JR MW limit which was Oscar natural fighting weight.

manny is fighitng margarito who has had 2 whole fights at the weight for a vacant title at a catchweight!!!

Floyd win over oscar is better than this whole fight regardless of who wins!

And that's the truth.