Better Offence....Whitaker Or Floyd?

[Perfect Plex]

????????????????

[Mr Punch]

Sweat Pea had a better defence and a better offence than Mayweather. Close the thread.

[S IP U IR S xII]

Floyd O Sweet Pea had the D

End of discussion.

[Joeyzagz]

Truly Great defensive fighters dont slur their words, so Mayweather obviously.

[Mr Punch]

Floyd O Sweet Pea had the D

End of discussion.

This applies to you then:

1. Jimmy Barry 58 - 0
2. Ricardo Lopez 51 - 0 - 1
3. Rocky Marciano 49 - 0
4. Edson Pedro Nascimento 47 - 0
5. Joe Calzhage 46-0
6. Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. 41-0
7. Floyd Mayweather Jr. 41-0
8. Sven Ottke 34 - 0
9. Jack McAuliffe 34 - 0
10. Michael Loewe 28 - 0
11. Edwin Valero 28-0
12. Laszlo Papp 27 - 0
13. Terry Marsh 26 - 0
14. Pichit Sit****prachan 24 - 0
15. Scott Daley 24 - 0
16. George Kandelaki - 24 - 0
17. Jemal Hinton 22 - 0
18. Mzukisi Skweyiya 21 - 0
19. Ike Ibeabuchi 20 - 0
20. Kirk Daley 19 - 0

[Thread Stealer]

I'm not really sure about this so I'll sit on the fence until I get a better analysis and then I'll jump off it.

Whitaker had the superior jab and workrate. Probably a better bodypuncher too, although Floyd is far from a slouch in that department. Whitaker's also probably better at pivoting his body in weird positions to get unusual angles on opponents. Whitaker did have some left hand power when he loaded up on it, but overall Floyd hit harder. He makes his punches count despite them being low in number, and hits hard & accurate enough to discourage or at least get the respect of most of his opponents. Floyd's straight right is more effective than Whitaker's straight left. Floyd's left hook is better than Whitaker's right hook. I'd say he also has the uppercut advantage over Whitaker.

Mayweather is better at walking guys down, as he's good at hiding behind the high guard, and either blocking and countering, or leading and then defending. Whitaker had this thing though where he could lead and then use his shoulder to back up opponents, and rough them up on the ropes (he did this to Chavez). Whitaker was probably a little better in the pocket although Mayweather is obviously terrific in the pocket too. Not sure whom I'd say is more effective on the backfoot or moving laterally. They both are very effective in this style.

[S IP U IR S xII]

This applies to you then:

1. Jimmy Barry 58 - 0
2. Ricardo Lopez 51 - 0 - 1
3. Rocky Marciano 49 - 0
4. Edson Pedro Nascimento 47 - 0
5. Joe Calzhage 46-0
6. Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. 41-0
7. Floyd Mayweather Jr. 41-0
8. Sven Ottke 34 - 0
9. Jack McAuliffe 34 - 0
10. Michael Loewe 28 - 0
11. Edwin Valero 28-0
12. Laszlo Papp 27 - 0
13. Terry Marsh 26 - 0
14. Pichit Sit****prachan 24 - 0
15. Scott Daley 24 - 0
16. George Kandelaki - 24 - 0
17. Jemal Hinton 22 - 0
18. Mzukisi Skweyiya 21 - 0
19. Ike Ibeabuchi 20 - 0
20. Kirk Daley 19 - 0

Whitaker..17 Ko's over double the fights Floyd had

[BoxerDood]

In his prime, Floyd was a better offensive fighter than Sweet Pea was. He was also a harder puncher in my opinion. However Sweet Pea probably had the better defense. I mean even at the end of his career he was making elite boxers swing at air for 12 rounds.

[American Dream]

This applies to you then:

1. Jimmy Barry 58 - 0
2. Ricardo Lopez 51 - 0 - 1
3. Rocky Marciano 49 - 0
4. Edson Pedro Nascimento 47 - 0
5. Joe Calzhage 46-0
6. Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. 41-0
7. Floyd Mayweather Jr. 41-0
8. Sven Ottke 34 - 0
9. Jack McAuliffe 34 - 0
10. Michael Loewe 28 - 0
11. Edwin Valero 28-0
12. Laszlo Papp 27 - 0
13. Terry Marsh 26 - 0
14. Pichit Sit****prachan 24 - 0
15. Scott Daley 24 - 0
16. George Kandelaki - 24 - 0
17. Jemal Hinton 22 - 0
18. Mzukisi Skweyiya 21 - 0
19. Ike Ibeabuchi 20 - 0
20. Kirk Daley 19 - 0

he said Mayweather O...Pea D

look you fumbling idiot..hes not saying 0(zero)..hes saying "O"..as in offense..so next time clarify before you start trying to make your dumb ass point..

now on to the topic..
Mayweather may have had slightly better offense..

[BigStereotype]

I think Floyd. Whitaker had better output, but Floyd's more accurate, more powerful and I think overall more skilled.