Margarito IN HIS Prime would never get dominated by a Kotelnik.

[Dick Buffman]

I'm suprised the comparison to the Clottey fight wasn't brought up sooner, even though I think Tony looked better vs Clottey than Devon vs Kotelnik but it wasn't by any means a dominating performance

The only thing not dominating about Tony/Clottey was the fact that Clottey stayed up.

But I had Tony winning pretty handily after the 4th round. Looked like Pac/Clottey only with less clean shots landed.

[markfrombrookly]

Well to be honest Margarito did get knocked out by a guy that used to fight at 135lbs

[-Kev-]

Margarito has fought at 154 several times most notably against Daniel Santos twice. Kotelnik has not fought above 140 lbs ever in his career and has fought as low as Lightweight. What is the meaning of this thread Chicano?

[Mr. Fantastic]

Margarito has fought at 154 several times most notably against Daniel Santos twice. Kotelnik has not fought above 140 lbs ever in his career and has fought as low as Lightweight. What is the meaning of this thread Chicano?

Sorry I didn't word it right. I meant a Kotelnik quality fighter.

[The Gambler1981]

Margarito probably would beat him, Maidana already did and not like he is a skillful guy he is a hard man also.

Alexander would probably beat a guy like Maidana though.

[King Ju-Ju]

Get the hell outta here with this Margarito thread Chicano.

[MACAQUEINBLACK]

Yea breaking a record isn't really shinning ok man. Clottey was broken down and couldn't handle the pressure. The decision went to the right person unlike the Kotelnik/Alexander fight.

Damn, you're sensitive.


Don't take every mildly critical comment about Margarito to heart. I was a supporter until the cheat controversy put a question mark over his career. Now I'm not sure how to appraise him exactly, he's a study in boxing contradiction in my eyes at this point.


Alexander had a high workrate in there, too. I said the cases were somewhat comparable, and they are...Margarito didn't look great however much he threw, period.

El Cabron got what I was saying when he stated,

"even though I think Tony looked better vs Clottey than Devon vs Kotelnik but it wasn't by any means a dominating performance"




What's the moral of the thread? Margarito >>> Alexander? Kind of irrelevant, no?


You set this whole dumb argument up, man, not me.

[Vadrigar.]

K ty. I guess I owe you a green k for being honest.

What's Margarito's got to do with Alexander/Kotelnik? Is this a lame attempt at uplifting a disgraced cheato?

[MACAQUEINBLACK]

What is the meaning of this thread Chicano?

Sorry I didn't word it right. I meant a Kotelnik quality fighter.

Even then, it's still a perverse thread.

[Eric Holder]

The only thing not dominating about Tony/Clottey was the fact that Clottey stayed up.

But I had Tony winning pretty handily after the 4th round. Looked like Pac/Clottey only with less clean shots landed.

Tony looked pretty horrible the first 4 rounds (or maybe Clottey just really impressed me)....but then again everyone looks pretty crappy against Clottey's high guard d


Tony's workrate in that fight was epic though