Comments Thread For: Paul Williams Given Two Options: Martinez or Dzinziruk

[15 Rounds]

Paul Williams is a beast! I dont mind who he fights im sure it will be very entertaining

[Ravens Fan]

[QUOTE=Calilloyd;8986305]

Okay you asked so here is the list and I did not make it up and it is spread evenly between wins and scored as a draw.

Unofficial Scores

Harold Lederman, HBO: Williams, 116-112

Kevin Iole, Yahoo! Sports: Margarito, 116-112

Tim Smith, New York Daily News: Draw, 114-114

Steve Springer, Los Angeles Times: Draw, 114-114

Bill Dwyre, Los Angeles Times: Margarito, 115-113

Steve Kim, MaxBoxing.com: Margarito, 115-113

Doug Fischer, MaxBoxing.com: Margarito, 115-113

Jerry Magee, San Diego Union-Tribune: Williams, 116-112

Robert Morales, Los Angeles Daily News: Williams, 115-113

Carlos Arias, Orange County Register: Williams, 115-113

David Avila, Riverside Press Enterprise: Draw, 114-11

4 out of 13 doesn't support your argument. And anybody that scored it for Margarito 116- 112 is delusional.

What argument was I making? I stated that there were some boxing writers that thought Margarito won and you asked for the list and I provided it. This is not my opinion it is fact. And it was four out twelve that believe Margarito won and four thought it was a draw and four went for Williams. So anyway you slice it that does not sound like a clear victory for Williams over a very flawed fighter that had to cheat to win. Williams should have dominate old plaster fist. Because after all he is the most feared fighter on the planet. Or, just maybe he is a tad bit overrated.

[Calilloyd]

[QUOTE=Ravens Fan;8988624]

What argument was I making? I stated that there were some boxing writers that thought Margarito won and you asked for the list and I provided it. This is not my opinion it is fact. And it was four out twelve that believe Margarito won and four thought it was a draw and four went for Williams. So anyway you slice it that does not sound like a clear victory for Williams over a very flawed fighter that had to cheat to win. Williams should have dominate old plaster fist. Because after all he is the most feared fighter on the planet. Or, just maybe he is a tad bit overrated.

"Plaster fist "was beating up every fighter put in front of him including Cintron and Cotto. So when you criticize Williams performance against Margarito you look like a serious hater

[Ravens Fan]

[QUOTE=Calilloyd;8988737]

"Plaster fist "was beating up every fighter put in front of him including Cintron and Cotto. So when you criticize Williams performance against Margarito you look like a serious hater

I don't know him so how can I possibly hate Paul Williams? And now you are claiming that I stated something that I never said. When did I criticize Williams performance against Margarito? Because I feel as if I wasn't even all that critical of Paul's performance. And if I did not make myself clear. What I meant to say is that if he is as half as good as his fans believe he is I believe he should have dominated such a flawed fighter such as Margarito. And I also stated, than provided the proof that you ask for, that some writers had thought that Williams had not won the fight. As far as how I felt about the fight, I actually thought it was a good close fight. And it was close enough that I would have to watch it again to say who I thought won. And not to get to far off track but in my opinion everything that Margarito has accomplished in the ring is suspect. And I personally believe he should be BANNED FOR LIFE from boxing. I can also honestly say that I have never hated any fighter. However, I can say that I have disliked some for being hot dogs, Vinny Pazienza comes to mind and I am even an Italian. In closing the bottom line is that I don't have to hate anyone to be of the opinion that they are overrated. And it is simply my opinion that Paul Williams happens to be a very flawed fighter who is very overrated. No more no less and there is certainly no hate involved.