give your top 5 ranking for the Jr WW

[wazaa.]

new rankings:

Based on resume:

1. Timothy Bradley
2. Amir Khan

3. Devon Alexander
4. Kotelnik
5. Maidana
6. Victor Ortiz

Based on skills:

1. Amir Khan

2. Devon Alexander
3. Timothy Bradley
4. Victor Ortiz
5. Kotelnik

[BEEHOP]

1.Khan
2.Alexander/Bradley
4.Maidana
5.Ortiz

[JK1700]

Bradley
Alexander
Khan
Maidana
Ortiz

[jrosales13]

1. Bradley
2. Khan
3. Alexander
4. Kotelnik
5. Maidana

Only reason why I have Alexander over Kotelnik is cuz Alexander "officially" has a win over him. And, some people do think Alexander won. Even though IMO Kotelnik clearly won. So that is my reasoning if it makes sense.

However, I can easily see why the majority would have Kotelnik over Alexander. And, I have no problem with that at all.

[jrosales13]

1.Khan
2.Alexander/Bradley
4.Maidana
5.Ortiz

Bradley
Alexander
Khan
Maidana
Ortiz

WTF? You have 2 guys that Kotelnik beat (1 official) over him? How is Madian and Alezander in your top 5 and not Kotelnik?

[AntDawg]

1. Khan
2. Bradley
3. Kotelnik
4. Maidana
5. Alexander

[BEEHOP]

WTF? You have 2 guys that Kotelnik beat (1 official) over him? How is Madian and Alezander in your top 5 and not Kotelnik?

Kotelnik lost his last 2 fights in a row. That does not earn you a top 5 ranking.

[IronDanHamza]

1. Bradley
2. Khan
3. Alexander
4. Kotelnik
5. Maidana

I have the same order and the same reasoning for why Alexander is above Kotelnik, although i thought Kotelnik won the fight..

[KillerRightHook]

I have the same order and the same reasoning for why Alexander is above Kotelnik, although i thought Kotelnik won the fight..

Based on Resume

1. Bradley
2. Khan
3. Alexander
4. Ortiz
5. Kotelnik

Based on Potential/Talent

1. Khan
2. Bradley
3. Ortiz
4. Alexander (Ortiz and Alexander, either could be #3)
5. Kotelnik

[ADozenArrows]

Khan
Bradley
Alexander
Judah
Maidana

This.