Taylor: New P4P Best?

[ottoevans]

exactly this is a ****** thread. Then you can say Tarver was #1 when he beat Roy Jones. Or That Hatton is #3 after he beat Kostya

[enadeus]

My new P4P:

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Marco Antonio Barrera
3. Ronald Wright
4. Erik Morales
5. Ricky Hatton
6. Juan Manuel Marquez
7. Manny Pacquiao
8. Zab Judah
9. Jermaine Taylor
10. Roman Karmazin

[Manny_P]

Tayler should crack top 10 P4P.

[enadeus]

Might as well remove Hopkins all together, he should retire. If he lost to a young fighter who's skills are still not at 100% there is no point of continuing fighting. Even if he avenges with a win over Taylor in a rematch he wont have enough time to fight RJJ if that fight should happen to avenge that loss as well. Too many losses to avenge, too little time.

[MrUnstoppable]

No way Winky is ahead of Morales

No way Morales is ahead of Winky. Not after the last fight with Barrera.

[-Nova-]

No way in hell Taylor is P4P the best. He didn't beat Hopkins, i don't care what anyone says, and won't hold the belts no where near as long as Hopkins. In the rematch, Hopkins has a definite win.

[BigIppoFireworks]

sorry to all the hatton fans out there, but beating an aging Kosta doesnt make you top ten... neither does beating a 40 year old Benard... P4P Jermain Taylor hasn't fought enough good opponents.

But it could be argued that in a couple of years Jermain could be P4P-Top5.

[abdiel2k3]

ive never thought beatin a p4p
makes u p4p
so no
i dont think taylor is p4p

wait
i take the back
it could make u a p4p
but its not like u take the guys place u beat
u just move up on the list
or start to make ur own case for being there
but my main point
u dont take over their spot

[Manny_P]

ive never thought beatin a p4p
makes u p4p
so no
i dont think taylor is p4p

great analysis Einstein.

[scottydottie]

new p4p??? WHOEVER WROTE THIS THREAD IS AN IDiot!!