Taylor: New P4P Best?

[TheEvilSaint]

do you think by beating bernard hopkins, is jermain taylor the new pound for pound best fighter in the world now?

IMO, no hes not. floyd mayweather is now the P4P best. taylor's still too green.

[sisforshaq]

No this just proves why Floyd is the p4p best. Taylor is probally top 10 now but Floyd just eases into the spot he desveres.

[Tha Greatest]

From what I hear, Taylor remains the same...


A BULL**** Decision don't deserve u #1..

[Hisoka]

You have to be kidding me. Floyd was p4p best before this fight.

[-Antonio-]

I think this keeps mayweather number 1 and put taylor in the top ten.

[MrUnstoppable]

Floyd Mayweather has been the best pound for pound fighter only now the picture is a little more clear. Winky Wright is now a clear #2. Jermain moves up in the Top 10. Even with a loss I don't think Bernard should drop very far.

[Sir_Jose]

No way is he #1 he barley made it to the end.

Floyd will be #1 now though

[enadeus]

When Hatton beat Tszyu that put him in the p4p top ten. Same with when Johnson beat Tarver. Same goes for Taylor.

[Sir_Jose]

Floyd Mayweather has been the best pound for pound fighter only now the picture is a little more clear. Winky Wright is now a clear #2. Jermain moves up in the Top 10. Even with a loss I don't think Bernard should drop very far.

No way Winky is ahead of Morales

[TyrantT316]

beating someone in the top10 p4p doesn't "automatically" give them that place...I wouldn't even put Taylor top 10...it is about domination and consistency...he beat an old Hopkins in a close fight that could have gone either way...Hopkins finished stronger..etc...

P4P rankings are and should continue to be about who beats who regardless of weight...are you actually convinced after tonight that Taylor beats a Morales, Barrera, JMM, Winky, Mayweather, etc P4P?