Pernell Whitaker vs. Manny Pacquiao @ 135

[Khalid X]

That's because most fantasy fights people post are ******, Pac got outboxed by a skilled boxer, so it's unlikely that he would beat one of the most skilled that ever lived.

Barrera has always been more skilled than Marquez prime for prime and Manny crushed Marco. I see where your going with this though..........

[Khalid X]

I actually just wanted to see if people were biased enough to pick Pac. Glad for the most part they weren't

And this is what I don't get. Why do you have to be biased to pick Manny? I mean this is what all these threads are about any way....just indirect ways to say Manny he beneath fighter A or Fighter B. Dude Manny is an ATG and one of the best in this era for a reason. People who think he has no chance or in no way would win are really the people who are biased. Now I truly respect Sweat Peas game as a fighter but Manny could beat him. Would he in a fantasy fight...well thats hard to say as both are legends. I'm sorry man but to think one ATG has no chance against another is a bit naive.

[oaklandstephen]

whitaker would probably hit the deck in this fight but he'd win by at least 8 or 9 rounds and get a ud.

[hugh grant]

Since when did Pernell use a shell defense? If you haven't watched Pernell, shut the fuck up instead, GOD.

I didnt mean a shell literally. I just mean he would chicken out with trading with Pac and would be negative, because Pacs tools are more efficient.


Pac hits harder and is faster.

[SkillspayBills]

You know who beats Whitaker at 135?




Noone.

[hugh grant]

And this is what I don't get. Why do you have to be biased to pick Manny? I mean this is what all these threads are about any way....just indirect ways to say Manny he beneath fighter A or Fighter B. Dude Manny is an ATG and one of the best in this era for a reason. People who think he has no chance or in no way would win are really the people who are biased. Now I truly respect Sweat Peas game as a fighter but Manny could beat him. Would he in a fantasy fight...well thats hard to say as both are legends. I'm sorry man but to think one ATG has no chance against another is a bit naive.

I really think some people are picking Witaker, out of spite. Trying to bring Pac down a peg or two. But dont think Witaker would beat Pac.

[Heeb]

And this is what I don't get. Why do you have to be biased to pick Manny? I mean this is what all these threads are about any way....just indirect ways to say Manny he beneath fighter A or Fighter B. Dude Manny is an ATG and one of the best in this era for a reason. People who think he has no chance or in no way would win are really the people who are biased. Now I truly respect Sweat Peas game as a fighter but Manny could beat him. Would he in a fantasy fight...well thats hard to say as both are legends. I'm sorry man but to think one ATG has no chance against another is a bit naive.

If you want to pick Manny, that is fine by me. The main reason I made this thread is I saw a thread where people were saying Manny was greater than Sweet Pea. Manny had a lot more votes than Whitaker which really surprised me. I don't mean to criticize your view and if you think Manny would win, I respect your opinion. But I think this forum tends to overrate Manny and Floyd. In this case, Pac by KO didn't dominate the poll like I thought it would, so I'm glad Whitaker is getting the respect he deserves.

[wizard king]

Barrera has always been more skilled than Marquez prime for prime and Manny crushed Marco. I see where your going with this though..........

but both of them lack what sweet pea has and thats speed and movement so no pac does not beat a prime sweet pea no matter what bs excuse you make up

[Toney Loc]

You know who beats Whitaker at 135?




Noone.

Prime Duran and Mosley come the closest, IMO.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I didnt mean a shell literally. I just mean he would chicken out with trading with Pac and would be negative, because Pacs tools are more efficient.


Pac hits harder and is faster

You really don't know what your talking about. How about this man, come talk when you've actually watched Pernell Whitaker, ok? Till then, I ain't tryin' to hear your bull****. You're really coming off as ******, not once have I ever opened my mouth on something I didn't have any acknowledge of, you should take the same advice.