Who is P4P #3 ???

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Its between Sergio, Wlad and Dawson.

For me, p4p lists = resume + skill level. Wlad and Dawson are highly skilled but dont have the resume of Martinez who obviously is also highly skilled.

3. Sergio
4. Dawson
5. Wlad

[frankenfrank]

Despite of Martinez' recent popularity , he was stopped in the past , unlike Marquez whom fought the 2 leading P4P fighters being smaller than both , and not getting stopped. Martinez was stopped by Margachito whom couldn't stop Williams despite of his cheating.
Marquez is still more proven than Martinez .
Martinez may be the #4.

[frankenfrank]

Its between Sergio, Wlad and Dawson.

For me, p4p lists = resume + skill level. Wlad and Dawson are highly skilled but dont have the resume of Martinez who obviously is also highly skilled.

3. Sergio
4. Dawson
5. Wlad

Seriously , No.
Wlad is so big and was stopped 3 times in the past by smaller men , is that P4P 4 u ?
Dawson ? was knocked down by a past it Eric Harding , got a gift decision against Glen Johnson when he should have gotten a 'L' , and was knocked down by a drained Adamek.
Martinez ? probably my #4 .

[frankenfrank]

Andre Ward

For what ? being dirty ?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Seriously , No.
Wlad is so big and was stopped 3 times in the past by smaller men , is that P4P 4 u ?
Dawson ? was knocked down by a past it Eric Harding , got a gift decision against Glen Johnson when he should have gotten a 'L' , and was knocked down by a drained Adamek.
Martinez ? probably my #4 .

Martinez got stopped over 10 ****in years ago....around the same time that Pacquiao got stopped. Knock downs? Seriously.....stfu.

Im a huge JMM fan. I had him p4p no1 before the Mayweather fight. Yes he was greatly disadvantaged in size but you cant completely disregard the way he was dominated. Adding to the fact hes been out a year and looks past his best. I think you might even see this Saturday that he isnt the 3rd best fighter in the world right now.

[JK1700]

Marquez is p4p #3, But he should be p4p#2 because he clearly beat Pacquiao in the 2nd fight. His loss to Floyd doesnt de-value him too much because he should have two victories over Pacquiao. The so called p4p#1

[frankenfrank]

Martinez got stopped over 10 ****in years ago....around the same time that Pacquiao got stopped. Knock downs? Seriously.....stfu.

How many quality opponents did each one of them have ?
Marquez has a big edge.

Im a huge JMM fan. I had him p4p no1 before the Mayweather fight. Yes he was greatly disadvantaged in size but you cant completely disregard the way he was dominated. Adding to the fact hes been out a year and looks past his best. I think you might even see this Saturday that he isnt the 3rd best fighter in the world right now.

He may lose a decision to the 10 years younger man he already stopped before , but until then and if it will happen at all , Marquez is still the #3 , after that , and only if , he may swap places with Martinez.
But maybe you will get the proof he is the #3 as I claimed.

[rochemback]

Juan Manuel Marquez or Sergio Martinez.
Chad Dawson is also up there, same for Shane Mosley, who I still rate.

[frankenfrank]

Juan Manuel Marquez or Sergio Martinez.
Chad Dawson is also up there, same for Shane Mosley, who I still rate.

Mosley too old to be #3 now , but he is definitely still in the top 10.
Wlad gets too much respect here . He is a dominant HW because of a weak era
and him not fighting his brother , but P4P ? it is a proof of the forum's weakness
if Wlad gets so much votes for being the P4P #3 .
Dawson ? not #3 , but maybe top 10.

[Bring It On]

We all know Floyd is #1 and Pac is #2...but who is #3? I pick Sergio

8 days ago you had him 7th in your "Gorilla Dogs P4P List *July Edition*".

What has happened since then?