Who is P4P #3 ???

[Franco2012]

yeah yeah dogeater.
If you put up a poll on an unbiased forum and ask about JMM vs Manny and Castillo vs Floyd i can bet you more people will vote JMM won than Castillo.

so you are saying that Boxingscene is biased?

it was already voted here and almost everyone voted for FLOYD CASTILLO 1 fight!

[fugu]

so you are saying that Boxingscene is biased?

it was already voted here and almost everyone voted for FLOYD CASTILLO 1 fight!

I think Pacquiao has more biased fans than Floyd at this site yes. That should be quite obvious, just check out midget lo... sry pinoy lounge.

[Gorilla Dogs]

Nope. Even if that KD didn't count, Williams still win by split decision.

1 judge had it a draw, 1 had it for Martinez, 1 judge was out to fuggin lunch

[Franco2012]

I think Pacquiao has more biased fans than Floyd at this site yes. That should be quite obvious, just check out midget lo... sry pinoy lounge.

I will report this racism to BPP!

[PACnPBFsuck]

How does beating Margarito put anyone top2 p4p?

Go ask Mosley if beating Margarito doesn't help, he went from the back of the line to the front of the bus.

[fugu]

1 judge had it a draw, 1 had it for Martinez, 1 judge was out to fuggin lunch

I had Martinez winning aswell, but it was not clear as day to most people. It is a very disputed fight with some picking Williams and others Martinez.

Your point about the KD is irrelevant. Even without it the scored would be 119-111, 115-114, 114-115 for Williams.

[fugu]

Go ask Mosley if beating Margarito doesn't help, he went from the back of the line to the front of the bus.

And what was Margaritos ranking then compared to now?

[Gorilla Dogs]

I had Martinez winning aswell, but it was not clear as day to most people. It is a very disputed fight with some picking Williams and others Martinez.

Your point about the KD is irrelevant. Even without it the scored would be 119-111, 115-114, 114-115 for Williams.

Im sayin the score card for williams with 119 is messed up man you should know that. Any real boxing fan who has a little ounce of a touch to score a boxing match knew Martinez won

[Heru]

Chad Dawson will fill into #3 nicely when he beats Pascal on points in Montreal.

Sergio is pretty close though and I honestly might have had him at #3 because IMO he beat another top 10 P4Per in Williams and a current top 5 Jr. Middleweight Cintron. The only thing that holds me back back is that those wins aren't official. Just like JMM's win over Pacquiao isn't. It's honestly a tossup between Dawson, Martinez, and JMM.

I already calculated Wlad's avg. weight against the avg. weight of his last 10 opponents and Wlad outweighing them by 11+ pounds. And taking into account that most of his opponents still are fat when they get into the ring, that's not P4P.

[fugu]

I will report this racism to BPP!

Go right ahead. And then you can go google for median height and realize it is not racism. Asian people are shorter than the average american. Science buddy. Can't dispute it.