The Better Boxer? Hopkins or Toney

[AintGottaClue]

A GREAT DEAL OF BOXING goes into being a counter puncher

i think hopkins is better then toney plain and simpel so i picked hopkins boxing pure boxer ability to box i liek hopkins whatever

[realheavyhands]

nard can adapt just like toney ..toney more skilled naturally but nard work ethic second too none

[Guest]

An intelligent, fast-handed counterpuncher who has caused mayhem in every division from Middle to Heavy... vs. a silly old man who runs away, stumbles and gets his rep by bashing up little guys?

I'd have to pick Slopkins, natch.

[guru]

i'd say nard is the better overall boxer, although toney is master boxer as well.. toney's best qualities are defense and counter punching, while nard does everything well...

[roberson2u]

both are great IMO...i think Hopkins is better but I like Toney more

[sisforshaq]

Id just go with Toney, but I didnt wanna say it to early in the thread. Thats probally because they are close in skill but me likeing James a lot pushes him over the edge.

[Living Legend]

The Better Boxer? Hopkins or Toney

Toney is an overall better boxer, but hopkins is more consistent. In my opinion, had toney stayed at middleweight we would have stopped talking about hopkins years ago...

[sisforshaq]

Toney is an overall better boxer, but hopkins is more consistent. In my opinion, had toney stayed at middleweight we would have stopped talking about hopkins years ago...

I would agree with that statement..

[oldgringo]

In a word: Toney

[BLKPANTHER]

I Think Hopkins Is A Better Boxer. Hopkins Is More Dedicated To The Sport . Toney Is Very Good , He Can Take A Punch And He Is Definitly Willing To Do What It Takes To Win. Hopkins Is A Better Adjuster. With Every Fight Hopkins Has A Different Game Plan. He Knows That Styles Make Fights.