NSB: Help me make our top ten pound for pound list.

[Tiozzo]

So does anyone have JMM at anything but number 3?

I wouldn't rank Marquez higher than the number 8, 9 or 10
he has been great in his last fights, but the beating he took at the hands of Floyd just drops him in the ranks I think

I wouldn't rank Ward just yet

[jrosales13]

Please in this list Dawson ahead of P-Will...

Pac and Floyd are obvious top 2 anyway you wanted I could careless. Personally I have Pac #1.

Martinez, Bradley and JMM are clearly top 10 P4P fighters.

So that is 7 names that should be in the top 10.

Donaire, Montiel, Adamek, Bute, Ward, Wonjongkam, Mosley, Cotto, Moreno, and Juanma.

Any 3 of those 10 names can round off the top 10.

[da beatdown]

Pacquiao/Mayweather are interchangeable personally so make them 1 or 2 doesn't matter.

3. Now I'm in the minority here but I believe Dawson should be at number 3 he's the only fighter to beat Adamek, and he's beaten Harding, Tarver, Johnson and if he beats Pascal he should definately beat at number 3. Combine that with Donaire's lack of decent opposition recently and Marquez drubbing at the hands of Floyd and his age concerns and I believe Dawson clinches the number 3.

4. Marquez

5. Martinez is my choice for number 5, he was robbed of a win against Cintron and IMO Williams and he has a win over Bunema and Pavlik.

6. Donaire

7. Williams

8. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam, resume and longevity is undeniable.

9. Andre Ward (I think he beats out Cabellero and Mosley, I'm a huge Mosley fan but Mosley is getting on and I don't believe he has the skills to compete at the elite level anymore due to his age but i'll still support the dude)

10. Lucian Bute/Wladimir Klitschko/ Adamek - Bute has solidifies himself with a relatively long title reign (for a current SMW anyway seeing as how everyone is losing and regaining titles) and has KO'd Andrade, Miranda, Berrio and beat Bika he's beaten the best of the rest at 168.

Wlad has cleaned out HW even though the division is weak he's reigned a long time beating out the weak but consistantly beating out the contenders and champions at the weight.

Adamek has wins over Paul Briggs, O'Neill Bell, Cunningham, Banks, Golata, Arreola and only one loss to Dawson. It's a hard fight for the 10th spot.

Now we're talking! dawson #3....but.......Williams#4(a win is a win) #5Marquez #6Martinez #7Bute#8Hopkins#9Mosley#10Adamek

[Red Rebel]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Nonito Donaire
5. Shane Mosley
6. Chad Dawson
7. Paul Williams
8. Sergio Martinez
9. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
10. Celestino Caballero

[Mojita]

and to think.. Had Cotto beaten Margarito, then DLH, then Clottey after that, he'd be P4P Number 1 today maybe - he's not even in peoples top 10, how one fight can throw it all away.