Who is the best SMW in the world?

[Bhopreign]

1Andre Direll - has not been doing too much around 168, lost a SD to Carl Froch - which I think is very fair, as he didn't doo much.

If Dirrell didnt do much in that fight, please show me what Froch did. Its hard to even find a decent, solid punch that Froch landed the whole fight.

[GTL]

Am I the only one who doesnt think that bute isnt anything special? i mean.. hes good. but if hes taking into deep waters he will drown

[GoogleMe]

If Dirrell didnt do much in that fight, please show me what Froch did. Its hard to even find a decent, solid punch that Froch landed the whole fight.

Froch hurt Direll more then once, so please don't say that.

[Tampatrader0468]

Am I the only one who doesnt think that bute isnt anything special? i mean.. hes good. but if hes taking into deep waters he will drown

I don't think I have ever seen Bute as warn out as he was against Andrade in the first match... Other than that I don't know how you could completely call him an out of shape fighter, or not conditioned. Nobody else has made him that tired... Hard to gauge just yet.

[Sam Donald]

Whoever wins the super 6

[Grimmer]

Has to be between Ward, Bute and Kessler. No way Dirrell can make it to the top 3. He lost to Froch.

And he almost won. Some people think he did, I'm from England, I was routing for Froch but deep down I though Dirrell beat him although with Dirrell's first half performance it was close.

Dirrell came of age in that fight, he went in their like a chicken shít and came out boxing the socks off Carl Froch even backing Froch up and fighting him and Dirrell almost won a points decision. In his next fight he went in their with the confidence which he ended the Froch fight with and absolutely schooled the biggest most dangerous puncher in the division and put his arse on the canvas.

The result for the Dirrell v Froch fight will mean very little in the great scheme of Dirrell's career (it could work out to be a positive now that he won't be arsed about some undefeated record, he won't be afraid to take on new challenges in risk of losing) but the change of attitude, the shift in confidence Dirrell showed in the Froch fight, matched with his boxing ability has put him on the path to be the best.

Right now, I'd say Andre Ward is the more rounded fighter with Dirrell being more rough around the edges, but I think Dirrell is the most naturally talented. And I think he can beat Ward.

Dirrell would have Bute and Kessler chasing shadows. But against Ward, that will be a very interesting match. Really looking forward to it.