Roach >>>>>>>> mayweather brothers combined......

[STRUGG]

and it aint even close..............................mayweathers are the most overrated trainer in boxing

[Shabba Rank$]

and it aint even close..............................mayweathers are the most overrated trainer in boxing

I can see Floyd Sr. being called overrated.

But how can you call Roger overrated when Roger wasn't really rated at all?

[Cuauhtémoc1520]

I think both are very good trainers in their own right. I think Roach is more of a technical coach and mayweather is more of a motivational type.

I remember Oscar saying he has never been pushed the way he was with Floyd Sr.

It also doesn't hurt when you have Pacquaio and Floyd to coach either...hahah

[ModernTalking]

Didn't Roach train Oscar De La Hoya when Mayweather beat him????

Roger >>>>>>>>> The Joke Coach Roach

Yea and Oscar won that fight but got robbed LOL....if you don't believe me you can ask Floyd Sr.

[Everlast2900]

Freddie roach's fighters > than Mayweathers fighters.......................

Once floyd retires we will not hear of Roger or Floyd sr again, they both are enjoying there 15 mins of fame. and its not like they have fighters beating down there door.
Roach on the other hand seems to have more coming and coming....Wonder who is next.

[V.WEBB]

Yea and Oscar won that fight but got robbed LOL....if you don't believe me you can ask Floyd Sr.

So now you believe "Floyd Crackhead Sr"...SMH.

[STRUGG]

I can see Floyd Sr. being called overrated.

But how can you call Roger overrated when Roger wasn't really rated at all?

floyd makes him look good....................some overrate him here in the boards though

[Shabba Rank$]

floyd makes him look good....................some overrate him here in the boards though

Of course Floyd makes Roger look good.

But that doesn't mean Roger should be overrated when the only name fighter he's trained is his nephew.

But he has great prospects in Jessie Vargas and Dione Smith that he's also training.

[Kalion]

Trainers get to much credit, Boxing isnt like football or basket ball where a lesser team with a better coach can beat a team with the opposite make up. In boxing spare stylistic mismatchs and lucky punches, the better man almost always wins. Trainers dont do much to affect the outcome.

With that being said, Roach is a great preparer. He analyzes fighters and find weaknesses extremely well. Hes also as of lately a hell of a match maker, see Pacs career. What Roach does best though take what a fighter is best at, and make him better at it.And the things they are worse at, make them decent in those areas.

The Mayweathers are also great at preparing for fighters. Yeah they claim to never watch film or pay to much attention to thier opponents style but its clear that they do. Floyds never seem clueless or lost about anything he has had thrown at him. Remember DLHs comeback fight against Mayorga? Has he ever looked sharper than that? Had he kept Sr as his trainner for the Floyd fight we may have seen a totally different fight. Given a fighter with the right tools, they can transform him into a force.

Roach is more decorated but they are both good in my opinion.

[Vegan101]

Roger is not a trainer, he's just being use by Floyd as a mitts holder.

Roger doesn't know **** about baxin.