whose competition was greater???...Cotto or floyd

[Madison Boxing]

cotto is the most overrated fighter in the last 20 years.

[IronDanHamza]

At no point in Cotto's career did he ever sniff Floyd's resume.

This place was (and is) utterly ridiculous.

Cotto was so overrated on here.

Even after the Margarito loss.

[bambam182]

Cotto fought.

Pacquiao
Mosley
Margarito
Clottey
Judah
Foreman
Quintana
Torres
Malignaggi


Mayweather fought.

Castillo
De La Hoya
Mosley
Marquez
Corrales
Hatton
Judah

Cotto's fought the better fighters.

the bottom 4 of cotto are worthless, dont try to justify. cotto got knocked out by pac, mayweather gave pac a boxing lesson. mayweather also fought hernandaz. if you are going to put someone like foreman for cotto than mayweather can have gatti on his list. ortiz and maidana are better then torres or quintana. they both fought the ginger with ginger losing to money and ginger punking down cotto.

mayweather over all the better fighter and resume. and i hate mayweather.

[CHOWWOKKA]

Since when are losses considered in a fighters resume?

[$tate of Mind]

Cotto

He fought Shayne Mosley, margarito and pacquio when they were all absolute beasts. He even gave Floyd bloody hell and Floyd himself said cotto was his toughest. He'll cotto even fought Canelo at caneloweight with a full three more years experience after he fought Floyd.

Floyd fought all these guys, except margarito of course, in compromised form.

Cotto lost to Manny and the 1st Margarito fight badly. Cotto also lost to Canelo. Why should he get credit for loses? It makes no sense. I like Cotto but his resume ain't all that. Mosley, Judah, Clottey, Geale, etc. is good but not great. Cotto arguably lost the Clottey fight and he lost to Trout.

[$tate of Mind]

Since when are losses considered in a fighters resume?

This places makes no sense so now losing enhances your resume

[Madison Boxing]

miguels record against top fighters

canelo- lost convincingly wide UD
martinez (a crippled old man)- won
mayweather- lost convincingly wide UD
trout- lost convincingly wide UD
margarito (prime version)- lost badly, beaten and stopped
clottey- controversial win- split decision
pacquiao- lost badly, beaten and stopped
mosley- his only decent win and he won by 1 round.

this is a world class CV is it? better than mayweathers 49-0 where if we compare opponents from the above list...

canelo- Wide UD
Pacquiao- wide UD
Cotto- wide UD
Mosley- wide UD.

[hugh grant]

Is this a trick question? Of course its Miguel, am I missing something?

[soul_survivor]

Interesting.

Cotto fought a prime Pac, Marg, Canelo, Martinez (pretty much shot and injured but most had Cotto as underdog) and a better version of Mosley (than both Pac and May). He officially holds only 2 wins from that grouping, although imo he beat Canelo too.

Mayweather fought a prime Castillo, Corrales and...I dunno, Judah?

Cotto has the better resume but Floyd has the wins.

[b00g13man]

Cotto was so overrated on here.

Even after the Margarito loss.

I'm still trying to figure out how anyone with any semblance of intelligence could deem Cotto as having a better resume at any point in time.

I'm seriously baffled.