Pacquiao Is already a top 10 ATG, a win over Mayweather puts him ahead of SRR.

[fugu]

This is ****ing hilarious.

I guess this means you illiterate fools put Mayweather in very high regards in an ATG discussion? If Pacquiao makes such a jump of greatness by beating him he (floyd) should rightfully be top3-4 p4p of all time?

Personally, i think you are all ******ed to even hint at either of them is top10 ATG. It is an insult to the old school great boxers.

[minasyan]

i will agree with you when pac wins the heavyweight title

126-1

robinson will never be defeated

[Boss2k10]

i will agree with you when pac wins the heavyweight title

126-1

robinson will never be defeated

Different eras of boxing.

If Pacquiao wins another title at 154 and beats Margarito OR just beats PBF.

Then what he would have achieved in this era would be more impressive than what SRR did in his. A flyweight beating WW will never ever happen again, a WW beating MW has happened before and will happen time and time again.

[NChristo]

Different eras of boxing.

If Pacquiao wins another title at 154 and beats Margarito OR just beats PBF.

Then what he would have achieved in this era would be more impressive than what SRR did in his. A flyweight beating WW will never ever happen again, a WW beating MW has happened before and will happen time and time again.

Just going to throw this out there as you mentioned a FW beating a WW will never happen again.

Where do you rate Barbados Joe Walcott ?, he was a WW beating HWs, which with the new rules is never going to happen again, a FW beating a WW is very much more likely.


Whatever Pac does is never going to be more impressive then what Ray Robinson did.

Jus Sayin.

[TheGreatA]

Georges Carpentier was a flyweight beating heavyweights. He must've been the greatest.

[check hook]

Different eras of boxing.

If Pacquiao wins another title at 154 and beats Margarito OR just beats PBF.

Then what he would have achieved in this era would be more impressive than what SRR did in his. A flyweight beating WW will never ever happen again, a WW beating MW has happened before and will happen time and time again.

how does beating a ***** cherry picking ducker add to another fighters legacy?

[bdevils]

[IMG]http://i442.***********.com/albums/qq145/Highermagneto/nortonscrewthis.gif[/IMG]

Lmfao!!

[Terrel]

Look, IF Pac-May takes place and Pac were to win I would say he's an ATG.

No ****ing way though, is he better or ahead of Sugar Ray Robinson! Without doubt, the greatest of ALL time #1.

[El Protagonista]

how does beating a ***** cherry picking ducker add to another fighters legacy?

I made a thread about this the other day. People spend so much time bashing Mayweather or Pacquiao and forget that if this fight happens it will be the best name on the winners resume. After the fight they will praise the loser like he was the GOAT.

[check hook]

I made a thread about this the other day. People spend so much time bashing Mayweather or Pacquiao and forget that if this fight happens it will be the best name on the winners resume. After the fight they will praise the loser like he was the GOAT.

indeed...............either way even if one wins over the other i'm still going to struggle to find a spot in my top 20 ATG for either one of them...........