Is Cotto now a sure HOFer?

[immortal tech]

Mosley very close fight
Judah props
Quintana props
Clottey very Close fight
Foreman so what?



if this guy gets in the HOF then lots of other B class boxers should get in 2 real talk

[JK1700]

Not too sure at the moment. I think it's dependent on who he fights in the coming year or so.

If he can unify 154lb division by beating Spinks and/or Dzindziruk that would make him 17-2-0 in world-title fights. Becoming undisputed champ would really help his case and I think he'd get into the HoF.

But I think he should try to cement his legacy by fighting Sergio Martinez, if he wins then I think he'd definitely get into the HoF, I'd also rank him in the top 4 or 5 P4P in the world too. but I think Martinez beats him. If Martinez can beat Cotto then maybe he's got a case for HoF if he can rematch Paul Williams and win, as well as unifying against Sturm and/or Sylvester.

That's the key, If he wins another big fight like Martinez or Williams then id put him in. If he fought another top guy and lost by KO again then I wouldnt be sure if you would have him in there. He's good but im not sure where he ranks among the best fighters of this era.

[Beater_of_ass]

Mosley very close fight
Judah props
Quintana props
Clottey very Close fight
Foreman so what?



if this guy gets in the HOF then lots of other B class boxers should get in 2 real talk

So what? Because he WON close fights the win isn't good enough? I guess since Mayweather didn't beat DLH by 10 rounds we should discredit that win.

[Kambumbo]

sure he does, only cotto haters say that he wont

[JK1700]

Mosley very close fight
Judah props
Quintana props
Clottey very Close fight
Foreman so what?



if this guy gets in the HOF then lots of other B class boxers should get in 2 real talk

I see where you coming from, Cotto has beaten about 10 world champions but alot of them like Quintana, Corley, Branco, Urkal and Jennings were pretty average fighters.

Cotto still has that lingering loss to Margarito also. Who has 6 losses

If Cotto beats Paul or Sergio that puts him in...

Otherwise you can't say he is a sure bet for the HOF

[Earl-Hickey]

I don't like Cotto much, his attitude rubs me up the wrong way at times, but I cannot deny he belongs in the hall of fame

[The Comedian]

So what? Because he WON close fights the win isn't good enough? I guess since Mayweather didn't beat DLH by 10 rounds we should discredit that win.

whos that in your avi

[Beater_of_ass]

whos that in your avi

I can't remember her real name, I just know her as Kimber from Nip/Tuck.

[immortal tech]

So what? Because he WON close fights the win isn't good enough? I guess since Mayweather didn't beat DLH by 10 rounds we should discredit that win.

look Cotto is a good fighter but not an elite if you lower that standers and let this guy in then HOF wouldn't be what it is and honestly you could make an argument for lots of other guy's that have no business being in there

[Beater_of_ass]

look Cotto is a good fighter but not an elite if you lower that standers and let this guy in then HOF wouldn't be what it is and honestly you could make an argument for lots of other guy's that have no business being in there

I still think he's on the cusp, one more win will make him a lock. I'm simply saying you can't put "barely" about a win. Not everyone is going to blow everyone out of the water.