My P4P Elite Top 10 list Video
Collapse
-
-
Dawson is no way in hell P4P number 5. I really don't think he's that impressive. I'd rate Billy Goat over him. Also, Martinez at 10 and Paul Williams at 4 is quite frankly a joke. You've got to rate them 4/5 if you want Williams that high... Maybe Martinez even higher than Williams.
Also, where is Adamek and why is Berto there?Comment
-
I think Wlad is too high, and Martinez too low. And Berto shouldn't be in there and instead put Marquez in there. I think Wlad is too high because while what you say is true, he has been barely losing a round and beating top competition, but he's slightly larger than his competition in most of his fights, that counts against his P4P ranking IMO.Last edited by Pirao; 05-27-2010, 02:39 PM.Comment
-
Fair enough, Martinez could be higher but according to my criterias (How dominant, Winning streak, Quality of recent opponents beaten) he didn't fit the bill.Nice vid but Martinez needs to be higher. You can't have Berto above Martinez under any circumstance
The quality of opponents beaten, he got covered in beating Pavlik and had he Ko'd him, i'd have him higher but he only won a decision. As far as his body of work before that, he just came off of a loss and he didn't beat anybody of value at 154. He won the Interim WBC 154 title and later got declared the FULL champ after Forrest died.
P. Will is on a (winning streak) one of my criterias for scoring. (How dominant) criteria - his domination of Winky was impressive even if The Wink was past his prime and inactive, nobody else could've handled him like that for 12 rounds and P.Will's size & skills had something to do with it. That's why he is ranked as high....1. For the way he handled Winky Wright and 2. Because he beat a future Middleweight champ in Martinez.Last edited by cupocity303; 05-27-2010, 02:48 PM.Comment
-
Well I disagree, he has dominated 90% of all his fights, his Adamek win is looking better and better considering how well Adamek was and is doing at Cruiserweight and now Heavyweight. His dominant win over Johnson was impressive as well. It was the equivelant to Floyd avenging his close fight against Castillo at 135, adjusting and outboxing him.Dawson is no way in hell P4P number 5. I really don't think he's that impressive. I'd rate Billy Goat over him.
As I said above, Dawson's win over him is looking better and better. He is on the outside looking in right now at #11 in my book.Also, where is Adamek and why is Berto there?Comment
-
Thank you for being so kind and your authoritarian position.
No challange on Berto, Bradley, Alexander (i've explained my position on those three, I have no regrets, they're the future of boxing along with Andre Ward, all have world titles, solid boxing skills and for the most part dominant fighters, Mayweather-esque.)
But Dawson - the best LIght-heavyweight in the world not even in the Top 10?
Maybe you're the one who sucks.Comment
-
Good Video but next time why dont you do it starting with 10 down to 1? i dont get why it starts at 1... it should be a countdown to 1Comment
. Your P4P list sucks. Bradley, Alexander, Dawson and Berto dont belong in there.
Comment